Chapter 11: Cost of Victory
The Seattle Police Department conference room smelled like burned coffee and exhaustion.
Hotch stood at the head of the table, file open in front of him, expression carved from granite. The rest of the team was scattered around the room—Gideon by the window, Reid with his notes, JJ on her phone coordinating with media, Elle leaning against the wall with her arms crossed.
Morgan and I sat across from Hotch.
The silence stretched.
"You breached an unsecured building without backup," Hotch said finally. His voice was level, which somehow made it worse. "Armed unsub. Multiple potential hostages. Unknown layout. No communication with command."
Morgan started to speak. I cut him off.
"I made the call. Morgan backed me, but the decision was mine."
Hotch's eyes shifted to me.
"Explain."
"Backup was fifteen minutes out. The victims had been captive for months—we didn't know their condition, didn't know if Voss was escalating. Every profile point said collectors become destructive when they feel their collection is threatened. If Voss saw law enforcement massing outside, he might have decided to 'preserve' his exhibits permanently."
"You're speculating."
"I was reading the situation. The generator was running. The music was playing. He was home. If we waited, he'd know we were coming. We had one chance at surprise."
The silence returned.
He's not wrong. I took a risk. It paid off, but it could have gone the other way.
"The victims are alive," Hotch said slowly. "All four are expected to make full recoveries. Nathan Voss is in custody with a confession already recorded."
He closed the file.
"That's the result. But if that clinic had been empty—if Voss had been somewhere else, if the building had been rigged, if any of a hundred other variables had gone wrong—we'd be having a very different conversation."
"I understand that, sir."
"Do you?" His gaze was steady. "Because in this unit, results matter. But process matters too. We don't save people by getting ourselves killed."
Morgan leaned forward.
"With respect, Hotch—Mercer read the situation right. The call was justified."
"The call was a gamble. This time, you won." Hotch stood. "There's no formal reprimand. The families of those women are grateful, and that counts for something. But trust is built in layers, Agent Mercer. You've earned one layer tonight. Don't assume it covers everything."
"Understood."
He left without another word.
The room exhaled.
Reid looked up from his notes.
"Statistically, the decision to breach early improved victim survival probability by approximately 34%, assuming Voss followed typical collector behavior patterns when confronted with—"
"Reid." Elle's voice was soft. "Not now."
He subsided.
JJ finished her call, gathered her things.
"Media's handled. We're clear to fly out in two hours." She paused by the door, looked at me. "For what it's worth, you did good tonight."
"Thanks."
The room emptied gradually. Morgan went to coordinate with local PD. Reid followed JJ out. Elle pushed off from the wall, moved toward the coffee machine in the corner.
I stayed in my chair, staring at nothing.
Hotch is right. It was a gamble. I had the system feeding me data, telling me Voss was there, showing me his weaknesses—but Hotch doesn't know that. To him, I'm a new agent who went cowboy on his second case.
"You're thinking too loud."
Gideon's voice. I hadn't heard him approach.
"Good instincts can become arrogance if you're not careful."
He sat down across from me, studying my face with those paper-colored eyes that saw everything.
"You were right this time. You read the situation correctly, made a decision, and it paid off. But you won't always be right. No one is."
"I know."
"Do you?" He tilted his head. "There's a difference between knowing something intellectually and knowing it in your bones. The first kind of knowledge makes you cautious. The second kind keeps you alive."
He's testing me. Still testing, even now.
"I took responsibility for a shared decision," I said. "Morgan backed me, but I made the call."
Gideon nodded slowly.
"That's uncommon. Most agents share blame when things go wrong and take credit when things go right. You did the opposite."
He stood, moved toward the door.
"Keep that quality. It'll serve you better than instinct ever will."
He left.
I sat in the empty room, head throbbing from Focus drain, body aching from the takedown.
One layer of trust. That's what Hotch said. How many layers does it take before they stop watching? Before I can actually do what I came here to do?
The coffee machine gurgled behind me.
"You look like hell."
Elle. She set a cup in front of me—black, steaming, exactly what I needed.
"Feel like it too."
She sat where Gideon had been, cradling her own cup.
"Morgan told me what happened in there. The takedown."
"Morgan likes to talk."
"Morgan likes to brag. There's a difference." She took a sip of her coffee. "He said you read Voss in about three seconds. Knew exactly where to hit him, how he'd move, when he'd be off-balance. Like you'd studied him for weeks."
Shit.
"Adrenaline," I said. "Training. You see enough bad guys, you start to recognize patterns."
"Uh-huh."
She didn't look convinced. But she also didn't push.
"I misjudged you," she said after a moment. "When you first showed up, I thought you were another soldier playing cop. All discipline, no instinct. Turns out I had it backward."
"I don't know if that's a compliment."
"It is." She finished her coffee, stood. "The women we saved tonight—Karen Chen was the only one who escaped on her own. The other four would have died in those cases if you hadn't made that call. That matters more than any protocol."
She started toward the door.
"Oh, and Mercer?"
I looked up.
"Morgan said you owed him drinks. I say you owe all of us." A small smile. "There's a bar near Quantico. Good whiskey, bad music. When we get back, first round's on you."
She left before I could respond.
[RELATIONSHIP SHIFT: ELLE GREENAWAY — TRUST LEVEL: WARMING]
[FOCUS: 30/50 — RECOVERING]
I dismissed the notification.
She's asking me for drinks. Not the team—me specifically. Elle Greenaway, who keeps everyone at arm's length, is reaching out.
I know what happens to her. The Fisher King. William Lee. The spiral. Can I change any of it? Should I try?
I finished my coffee, tossed the cup.
Those questions didn't have answers yet. But for the first time since arriving in this world, I felt like I might find them.
The jet took off two hours later.
I fell asleep somewhere over Montana—real sleep, deep and dreamless, the kind I hadn't had in weeks. When I woke up, there was a blanket over me that hadn't been there before.
Morgan was reading a magazine across the aisle. He didn't look up.
Elle's seat was empty. But her card was on my armrest, a phone number scrawled on the back.
"For when you want that drink Morgan mentioned. Someone's got to hear his version of the story."
I pocketed the card.
Something had shifted. Not just with Elle—with all of it. The team, the system, my place in this world.
One layer of trust earned. More to go.
But it was a start.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!