Chapter 13: The Prophet — Part 1
Three weeks had passed since the bar.
Three weeks of cases—a spree killer in Memphis, a kidnapping ring in Phoenix, the usual parade of human darkness that made up BAU life. Three weeks of late nights and early mornings and moments stolen between briefings.
Three weeks of Elle.
We hadn't defined what we were. Didn't need to. Some nights we grabbed drinks after work. Some nights we talked on the phone until one of us fell asleep. Once, after a particularly brutal case involving children, she'd shown up at my apartment with whiskey and silence, and we'd sat on my couch until dawn watching bad television and not talking about what we'd seen.
It was something. Something good.
But today, the bullpen had a different energy.
JJ stood at the front of the conference room, crime scene photos already cycling on the screen. The images were wrong in a way that made my stomach clench—not the usual blood and violence, but something more insidious.
Bodies arranged like prayers. Notes written in flowing script. Faces frozen in expressions of peace.
"The Garden of Truth," JJ said. "It's a religious community about forty miles outside Austin, Texas. Population roughly fifty adults and twelve children. Leader calls himself The Shepherd."
[CASE FILE DETECTED]
[PROFILE TYPE: CHARISMATIC MANIPULATOR — HIGH DANGER CLASSIFICATION]
[FOCUS: 50/50]
Reid was already flipping through his notes.
"In the past six months, three former members of the compound have committed murder-suicide in surrounding communities. Each left identical notes praising The Shepherd and describing their deaths as 'graduation to a higher plane.'"
"Folie à deux," Gideon said quietly. "Shared psychotic disorder. The Shepherd convinces his followers that death is transcendence."
"But he hasn't technically committed a crime," Hotch added. "Local authorities have investigated twice. No weapons on the compound. No evidence of imprisonment. The members stay voluntarily."
Morgan leaned back in his chair.
"So he's just... talking people into killing?"
"He's identifying vulnerable individuals and systematically dismantling their sense of reality," Reid explained. "Classic cult indoctrination follows a predictable pattern: isolation from support networks, sleep deprivation, dietary control, repetitive messaging, love bombing followed by conditional approval—"
"Reid." Hotch's voice was gentle but firm. "The point is, we can't arrest him for being persuasive. We need evidence of direct involvement in the killings."
The room went quiet.
I studied the photos on the screen. The three "graduates"—a middle-aged accountant from Houston, a young mother from San Antonio, a retired teacher from Dallas. Nothing obvious connecting them except their time at the compound.
But there's always a connection. Cult leaders don't choose randomly. They select for specific vulnerabilities.
"What's the plan?" Elle asked.
Hotch stood, moving to the board.
"Reid and Gideon will analyze the suicide notes for linguistic patterns. Morgan and Elle will track down former members who left the compound—see if anyone's willing to talk about what happens inside."
He paused, looked at me.
"Mercer, you're with me. We're going to approach the compound directly under cover of a welfare check. Former law enforcement, current FBI—we have legitimate reason to verify the children are safe."
First time partnered with the boss.
[ASSIGNMENT: HIGH-RISK PSYCHOLOGICAL ENGAGEMENT]
[RECOMMENDATION: MAINTAIN MENTAL DEFENSES]
"Yes, sir."
The briefing broke apart into controlled motion. I was gathering my things when Garcia appeared at my elbow, colorful as always but with something serious in her eyes.
"Got a minute, newbie?"
"For you? Always."
She pulled me aside, away from the others.
"Look, I know you've seen some dark stuff. Kosovo, the cases we've worked. But cults are different." Her voice dropped. "They get inside your head even when you know what they're doing. The good ones can make you doubt things you've believed your entire life."
"I'll be careful."
"I know you will. But careful isn't always enough." She touched my arm—quick, warm, genuine. "Stay frosty, okay? I've got too much emotional bandwidth invested in this team to lose anyone to a guy in a white robe."
I smiled despite myself.
"I'll stay frosty. Promise."
She nodded, satisfied, and disappeared back toward her lair.
Garcia. Always watching, always caring. The heart of this team.
I remembered the first day—her terrible coffee, her immediate warmth. That felt like a lifetime ago.
The jet was wheels up within the hour.
Texas sprawled beneath us, brown and gold under the autumn sun. Hotch sat across from me, reviewing compound blueprints on his tablet.
"You've dealt with psychological operations?" he asked without looking up.
"Army CID worked some cases involving cult-adjacent groups. Militia compounds, sovereign citizens, the usual extremist overlap."
"This is different. Thorne—The Shepherd—doesn't use force. He doesn't need to. By the time his followers realize what's happening, they've already given him everything."
"What's his background?"
Hotch handed me a file.
Marcus Thorne. Fifty-two years old. Born in rural Oklahoma, raised in a series of foster homes. No criminal record. Founded the Garden of Truth eight years ago after a "spiritual awakening." The compound was technically a religious nonprofit, funded by donations from members and their families.
Nothing overtly suspicious. Which made it worse.
"The Bureau's looked at him before," Hotch continued. "Twice. Both times, the investigation stalled because there was nothing actionable. The members aren't prisoners. They're believers."
"And believers die for their faith."
"Exactly." He closed his tablet. "When we go in, let me lead. Thorne will try to establish dominance immediately—eye contact, personal questions, anything to find a crack. Your job is to observe, not engage."
"Understood."
The jet began its descent.
[MISSION PARAMETERS: OBSERVATION AND DOCUMENTATION]
[THREAT LEVEL: PSYCHOLOGICAL — HIGH]
[RECOMMENDATION: MINIMIZE DIRECT ENGAGEMENT WITH PRIMARY TARGET]
I dismissed the notification, but the warning lingered.
Charismatic manipulators. The system flagged them as high danger.
Why? What does it know that I don't?
The answer would come soon enough.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!