Cherreads

Chapter 4 - The Second Sister

GRACE POV

The coffee had gone cold three hours ago.

Grace Winters stared at the acquisition report on her desk and tried to focus. Numbers usually made sense to her. Numbers were honest. They didn't lie or betray you or fall apart when you needed them most.

But today even the numbers felt heavy.

Behind her, floor-to-ceiling windows showed Manhattan in daylight. The same city that had watched her brother drown. The same city where Marcus Sterling had walked into rooms and destroyed lives like it was a game.

A knock on her door pulled her attention away.

William stood in the doorway looking like a ghost of himself. He'd lost weight. Moved slower. Smiled like smiling cost him something he didn't have anymore.

"You're working too late again," he said.

Grace glanced at the clock. 11:47 PM. She'd been in the office since 7 AM.

"Someone has to," she said, keeping her voice light.

William came in and sat across from her without asking. He did that now. Before the destruction, her brother had been confident. Had walked into rooms like he owned them. Now he moved like he was asking permission just to exist.

"You didn't have to do this," he said.

"Do what?"

"Any of this. Dad's company was gone. You could have walked away."

Grace set down her pen and looked at her brother. Really looked at him. She could see the exhaustion in his face. The way his hands trembled slightly when he thought no one was watching. The knowledge that he'd built something and watched it burn.

"The company wasn't gone," she said. "It was broken. There's a difference."

"Grace, you were working at a marketing firm. You were happy."

She had been happy. That was the thing about the destruction. It had ruined more than just the Winters family business. It had ruined the possibility of her just being normal. Being satisfied with a good job and a safe life.

When Marcus Sterling destroyed her brother, he'd destroyed her too.

"I was comfortable," Grace corrected. "There's a difference between comfortable and happy."

William stood to leave and then stopped. "I heard they arrested him. Marcus Sterling. Federal charges. He's bankrupt."

Grace felt something cold move through her chest.

"Good," she said.

But it didn't feel good. It felt empty.

After William left, Grace sat alone in her office with the cold coffee and the acquisition reports. The city glowed beneath her like a living thing. She'd spent five years building Winters & Co from rubble. Five years of sixteen-hour days and impossible deals and learning how to negotiate with people who wanted to destroy her just because her last name was Winters.

Five years of wondering if revenge was even possible.

Victoria appeared in her office without knocking. That was the thing about Victoria. She showed up when Grace needed her, even when Grace didn't know she needed her.

"You're thinking about doing something stupid," Victoria said.

Grace looked at her best friend. Victoria had been there through all of it. Had helped her rebuild. Had been the voice of reason when grace wanted to burn everything down out of sheer rage.

"I don't know what you're talking about," Grace said.

"Marcus Sterling. I can see it in your face. You're thinking about him."

Grace turned away. Victoria always knew.

"He's finished," Victoria continued. "He's exactly where he deserves to be. Let it go."

"What if he's not?"

"Not what?"

"Not finished. What if he learns from this? What if he becomes something different?"

Victoria sat down and pulled the chair close to Grace's desk. "Grace, that man destroyed your brother. He destroyed your family. And you want to what, exactly? Give him a second chance?"

Grace didn't answer immediately. She was thinking about her father. Thinking about the way he'd looked the day Sterling's takeover went through. The way hope had drained from his eyes. He'd had a heart attack six months later. The doctors said it wasn't related. Grace knew better.

Marcus Sterling had killed her father as surely as if he'd pointed a gun at him.

"I want to know if he can bleed," Grace said finally.

Victoria leaned back like she'd been slapped.

"He's already bleeding," Victoria said. "Let that be enough."

But it wasn't enough. Grace had spent five years watching Marcus Sterling face no consequences. Yes, he'd lost money. Yes, he'd lost his company. But he'd done it to himself. He'd broken his own life when he decided to destroy someone else's.

Grace wanted him to understand what it felt like to be broken by someone else's choice.

After Victoria left, Grace pulled up Marcus Sterling's information on her computer. The bankruptcy filing. The criminal charges. The photos of him looking hollow. She read through articles about his fall and waited to feel satisfied.

She didn't.

Instead she found herself thinking about what her father had said once when she was young. Something about how the opposite of love wasn't hate. It was indifference. And a man who could inspire that kind of hate still mattered in some way.

Marcus Sterling still mattered to her family.

Which meant he couldn't be allowed to just disappear.

Grace picked up her phone and called her investigator. It took him two hours to find Marcus's current number. Two hours to trace him to a motel in Queens. Two hours to confirm that he was exactly as broken as the news said.

She typed out a message and hit send before she could change her mind.

"Interview tomorrow. Winters & Co. 9 AM. Come alone."

The response came faster than she expected. Like he'd been waiting for someone to call. Like he understood on some level that someone would find him.

"I'll be there," he wrote back.

Grace set down her phone and felt her heart start to race. What was she doing? Victoria was right. This was insane. This was reckless.

This was exactly what her brother needed to see. That people could fall and stand back up. That destruction wasn't the end of everything.

But it was also dangerous.

Because watching a man like Marcus Sterling try to rebuild himself would mean seeing him as human. Would mean acknowledging that he was capable of change. And if he could change, if he could truly transform from the predator he'd been into something better, then what did that say about forgiveness? What did it say about second chances?

What did it say about her?

Grace stood and looked out at the city. Tomorrow morning Marcus Sterling would walk into her office. Tomorrow morning she would meet the man who'd destroyed her family. Tomorrow morning she would take the biggest gamble of her career and her life.

She would look him in the eye and offer him a choice. Work for her. Prove himself. Show that redemption was possible or be destroyed by someone who finally understood how to play his own game.

The elevator dinged downstairs. She heard footsteps in the lobby. Her security team making their final rounds.

Grace turned off her office light and gathered her things.

Tomorrow everything would change.

She just had to survive the next eighteen hours.

Her phone buzzed one more time.

A second message from the same unknown number.

"Thank you for this. I don't deserve it. But thank you."

Grace's hands went still.

That message. Those words. They weren't from someone broken by circumstance. They were from someone who understood exactly what he'd done. Someone who might actually be capable of genuine change.

Or someone brilliant enough to fake it.

She pocketed her phone and walked toward the elevator.

Tomorrow morning she would find out which one he was.

And she had absolutely no idea that finding out would change her entire life.

More Chapters