Cherreads

Chapter 42 - Contradiction of Order

PROTO-EXIST vs. HEAVENLY DAO

The First Error versus the Heavenly Way

This is not a conflict of power,

but rather an ontological contradiction.

If the Outer God is chaos from without,

then the Heavenly Dao is perfection from within.

---

Party Definition

PROTO-EXIST

Status: First Cosmic Error

Essence: Possibility without existence

Principle: "I can exist, even though I shouldn't."

Tier: -1½

Fatal Traits:

No position

No cause

No end

It was 1 before the system knew how to count.

---

HEAVENLY DAO (天道)

Status: The Totality of Laws that Becomes the Way

Origin: Perfect Resonance of the Great Clock

Essence:

All laws → one flow

All causes → one direction

All results → inevitability

The Dao is not a conscious entity

The Dao is a cosmic necessity.

If the Great Clock is the engine of law,

then the Heavenly Dao is how that engine must run.

---

Meeting Ground

Called by the Zodiacs:

> Inevitable Trajectory

Here:

There is no choice

There are no coincidences

Everything must be on track

Except… Proto-Existent.

---

First Clash

When Proto-Existent "steps" into the Dao:

Heavenly Dao Reaction:

No attack

No rejection

No recognition

The Dao immediately attempts to assimilate.

📌 For the Dao, everything must be part of the Way.

---

Fatal Problem

The Heavenly Dao operates on the basis of:

Cause → Process → Effect

Proto-Exist has:

❌ Cause

❌ Process

❌ Effect

Effect:

> The Dao cannot process Proto-Exist.

Not because it is weak,

but because there is no valid input.

---

Dao Response: Absolute Correction

The Dao attempts one thing:

Elimination through Necessity

Returning Proto-Exist to its "proper position"

Making it impossible

But herein lies the paradox:

Proto-Exist never "should" have existed,

but it was already possible.

The Dao can only eliminate what deviates from the path,

not what has never been on the path.

---

Turning Point

When the Dao failed to correct itself,

for the first time in cosmic history:

> The Heavenly Path forked.

Not physically,

but conceptually.

Something called:

Probability Without Destiny

And it originated from Proto-Exist.

---

Why Heavenly Dao Can't Prevail

The Dao only works when:

There is structure

There is order

There is certainty

Proto-Exist is:

Zero structure

Zero order

Zero certainty

The Dao cannot eliminate possibility,

because the Dao itself is born from the first possibility.

---

Why Proto-Exist Can't Prevail

Proto-Exist can:

Disturb

Obfuscate

Make the Dao doubtful

But Proto-Exist cannot replace the Dao,

because it provides no path,

only a loophole.

A world without Dao:

Not destroyed

But not progressing

---

Final Result (World Canon)

❖ No destruction

❖ No domination

What happens is:

THE CRACK OF THE HEAVENLY PATH

Since this encounter:

Destiny is no longer absolute

Cultivation can fail or exceed its limits

Certain beings can:

Reject fate

Jump levels without cause

Be born without a destiny line

They are called:

> Deviants of the Path (逆道者)

---

Ultimate Truth

> Outer Gods threaten the existence of the world.

Proto-Existents threaten the meaning of the world.

Heavenly Dao threatens the freedom of the world.

And when Proto-Existents meet Heavenly Dao:

> For the first time,

Heaven is unsure of its own path.

---

More Chapters