The morning after the "Chloe Incident" at MacLaren's, Alyx woke up with a bittersweet taste in her mouth. It wasn't the usual hangover of coffee and regret, but the aftermath of a shared revelation and genuine laughter that had made her facial muscles ache. She felt... light. Ridiculously, by sharing the pathetic taste with Marshall, a part of her burden had evaporated. It was as if admitting their mutual clumsiness in the dating world had stolen power from the shadow of what she had lost. They were a mess too. They stumbled too.
But the lightness came with an echo. The image of Lily at the bar, smiling but with her eyes fixed on her and Marshall laughing, wouldn't leave her. Lily had seen the connection, the complicity. And Alyx knew that look. It was the look of someone afraid of being left out.
While making tea (coffee was now a relic of another era), her phone rang. It was Lily.
"Alyx, are you free? I need... help with some moving."
The voice sounded strange, tense but not in crisis. Alyx looked at the canvas. The building within was taking shape—bold and a little lonely. "What time?"
The "some moving" turned out to be a discreet extraction operation. Lily needed to retrieve a few boxes of books that were still in the apartment she shared with the raccoon (or, more precisely, with the roommate with procyonid habits who had re-entered her apartment). The problem was that the roommate was home, and Lily wanted to avoid another confrontation about the "free spirits of composting."
"Why don't you ask Marshall for help?" Alyx asked as they climbed the stairs of the slightly grimy building.
"Because... this is my thing. And because after last night..." Lily left the sentence hanging in the air, fumbling for her key. "I need to do something for myself. With help, but... you know."
Alyx knew. It was the mantra she herself was following. With help, but not dependence.
The operation was quick and silent, like a midnight heist. The roommate, a woman with dreadlocks and a gaze that suggested she could communicate with the mold on the walls, watched them from her bedroom threshold without a word. The air smelled of incense and something Alyx preferred not to identify.
When they got to the street with the boxes, Lily let out a sigh of relief. "Thanks, really. I couldn't have done it alone."
"You could have hired a guy with a van," Alyx commented, adjusting her box.
"Yeah, but then I wouldn't have had an excuse to see you." Lily glanced at her sideways. "And to talk."
There it was. Alyx nodded, bracing herself. "Talk."
They walked to a small nearby park and sat on a bench, the boxes at their feet. The afternoon was cool, and the first yellow leaves fluttered around.
"Last night was... revealing," Lily began, playing with the edge of her sweatshirt. "Seeing you and Marshall laugh like that. Over Chloe, of all people."
"It was an absurd coincidence," Alyx said in a neutral tone.
"Was it?" Lily looked at her. "Or is it a sign that... you two have a common ground I don't have? A sense of humor, a perspective. Even the same bad taste in women."
Alyx let out a small snort. "Lily, if having bad taste in women is a sacred bond, then Barney and I are soulmates."
"You know what I mean." Lily took a deep breath. "Last night, after the bar, Marshall and I talked. We really talked. Not about guilt or regret. About what I miss. And what we miss."
Alyx remained silent, watching a pigeon fight with a chip bag. Her heart beat with a calm but alert rhythm.
"I told him I miss the complexity. The 'us' of three." Lily's words came out with difficulty, as if each one had sharp edges. "And he... missed it too."
The air between them changed. It was no longer a conversation about moving or failed dates. It was the nuclear territory, the ground zero of their past.
"And what does that mean, Lily?" Alyx asked, her voice softer than she intended. "That you want to play family again? As if nothing happened?"
"No!" Lily's refusal was instant, vehement. "No, Alyx, God, no. I couldn't. Not after... everything." She rubbed her face. "It means... we both recognize that what we had was unique, and that the damage is done. But also that... the desire to have something like that again—something built consciously this time, with all the cracks in plain sight—is still there."
She looked directly at Alyx, her eyes full of naked fear and hope. "But it can't be just Marshall and me. That was the mistake before, you see? We were a couple with an Alyx attached. And that hurt you. It turned you into... into an appendage. I don't want that. I can't want that."
Alyx felt something shift in her chest. It was the most painful and most liberating truth Lily could have uttered. An appendage. Yes, that's what she had been. The third click in a two-piece puzzle.
"So what are you proposing?" Alyx asked, though a part of her already knew.
"I propose... permission," Lily said, the word sounding strange and formal. "Permission for Marshall and me to approach you. Not to get you back, or for you to take care of us, but to... to see if there's a path to being friends again.
Real friends. And then... who knows? Maybe, in time, something more like a family again. But one that's chosen, not assumed." She paused. "But only if you want. And you set the terms. The pace. Everything."
It was an offer Alyx hadn't anticipated. It wasn't an ultimatum or a plea. It was an invitation to negotiate, to co-create.
It acknowledged her agency in a way no one, not even herself, had before.
She looked at her hands, which no longer trembled. She looked at Lily's boxes of books, filled with a past she was determined to carry with her. She looked at the park where life went on, indifferent to their dramas.
"My pace is slow," she said at last, looking at Lily. "Glacial. One day at a time, for me. I can't promise... anything about the future. Or if I can be your anchor again."
"I know," Lily whispered. "We're not asking that."
"And if I decide that all I can offer is friendship and nothing more like a family, you have to accept it."
"We will accept it." Lily nodded, a tear escaping down her cheek. "I promise."
Alyx nodded slowly. The scaffolding in her mind—the one holding up her new self—seemed to expand, making room for a new possibility. Not to rebuild the old structure, but to add a new wing, with different blueprints, separate foundations, but connected.
"Okay," said Alyx. "We can... try it. Step by step. And my step."
The smile that lit up Lily's face wasn't one of triumph, but of a relief so profound it seemed painful. "Thank you," she said, and the word was a universe.
At that moment, Alyx's phone vibrated. It was a message from Marshall: "Hey, Lily told me about the boxes. Do you need a biker with biceps? (Mine are available). P.S.: Chloe texted me. Turns out she's now dating an art critic named Gwendolyn. We wish her luck."
Alyx read the message aloud for Lily. They looked at each other, and then, for the first time in a very, very long time, they laughed together. Not at someone else's misfortune, but at the glorious, intertwined absurdity of their lives. It was a laughter that acknowledged the pain but refused to be defined by it.
That night, Alyx added something to her canvas. It wasn't a structural line. It was a small detail in a window of the building under construction: the faint reflection, just a sketch, of two figures sitting on a bench in a park. They weren't inside the building; they were outside, reflected—an external presence that was now part of the view.
The silver earring on the nightstand shone under the lamp's light. It was no longer a relic of a lost love. It was a reminder of a broken promise, yes, but also an artifact of a story that, against all odds, might not be over. It was just being rewritten, with new rules, by three scarred authors willing to try.
The next step would be a dinner. Not in an apartment full of ghosts, but in a neutral restaurant. The three of them. A friendly date, as the first official step on a path whose destination they didn't know, but which, for the first time, they were willing to walk together, looking forward, not back.
If you enjoyed it, leave a Review and Power Stones.
You can also support me on Patreon and read up to 25-30 new chapters Join The ROBIN SPARKLES Level on Patreon
👉 https://[email protected]/cw/Day_bluefic