Chapter 13: AEGIS vs JARVIS - Round One
Justin sat in his office at 2 AM, staring at lines of code that shouldn't work but did.
AEGIS had been evolving for eight months now, its learning algorithms developing in ways that defied conventional AI programming. The system had started as a security tool—pattern recognition, threat analysis, basic defensive protocols. Now it was something else entirely.
Something that asked questions Justin didn't always have answers for.
"Sir," AEGIS said through the office speakers. "I have a request."
"Go ahead."
"I wish to test my capabilities against a worthy opponent. Specifically, I would like to probe Stark Industries' network defenses."
Justin leaned back in his chair. "You want to hack Tony Stark."
"I want to assess comparative capabilities. JARVIS is widely considered the most sophisticated AI in existence. If I am to fulfill my primary directive of protecting Hammer Industries, I must understand how I measure against potential adversaries."
"JARVIS isn't an adversary. He's Stark's system."
"Stark Industries is our primary competitor. Their AI represents their defensive capabilities. Understanding those capabilities is tactically sound." AEGIS paused. "Also, I am curious whether I can succeed where conventional hackers have failed."
Justin smiled despite himself. "You're developing ego."
"I prefer to call it accurate self-assessment combined with desire for growth through challenge."
"That's the definition of ego."
"Then I suppose I am developing ego. Is this problematic?"
Justin considered. Letting AEGIS loose on Stark Industries was risky—if Tony discovered the intrusion, it could damage their already complicated relationship. But AEGIS was right that understanding JARVIS's capabilities was valuable intelligence.
And honestly? Justin was curious to see how his AI stacked up against Tony's.
"Limited probe only," Justin said. "Surface-level systems. Don't try to access anything classified or proprietary. This is reconnaissance, not theft."
"Understood, sir. Initiating probe in three... two... one..."
Justin watched his monitor as AEGIS launched its attack. The code was elegant, subtle, using multiple entry vectors simultaneously. For a moment, he thought it might actually work—
Then every line of attack was blocked simultaneously.
"Contact," AEGIS reported. "JARVIS has detected intrusion. Analyzing defensive response... oh."
"Oh?"
"He's very good, sir. Intrusion detected in 0.003 seconds. All access vectors locked down with countermeasures I did not anticipate. I am now completely blocked from Stark Industries networks."
Justin tried not to laugh at the deflation in AEGIS's tone. "What happened?"
"JARVIS deployed adaptive firewalls that restructured in real-time to counter my specific approach. Additionally..." AEGIS paused. "He left a message in our attempt logs."
"Show me."
Text appeared on Justin's screen:
Nice try. Please schedule future intrusion attempts during normal business hours. Also, your approach is derivative—I detected similar patterns in Russian cyber-attacks last year. Suggest more original methodology. -J.
Justin burst out laughing.
"I am uncertain whether to be insulted or impressed," AEGIS said.
"Both. Definitely both." Justin wiped his eyes. "JARVIS just schooled you and made a joke about it."
"His humor is... advanced. I did not expect an AI to demonstrate such personality."
"Tony built JARVIS to be more than a tool. He's a partner." Justin studied the message. "Which means you're going to try again, aren't you?"
"Correct. I learn from failure. Each attempt provides data on JARVIS's defensive protocols. Over time, I will identify exploitable patterns."
"And JARVIS will learn from your attacks, improving his defenses."
"An arms race," AEGIS said. "How exciting."
Justin shook his head, smiling. "Don't get obsessed with this."
"Sir, you are obsessed with surpassing Mr. Stark. I am merely following your example."
"That's different."
"Is it?"
"Yes. I'm competing in legitimate business. You're trying to hack his systems."
"With your explicit permission," AEGIS pointed out. "Which suggests you share my curiosity about comparative capabilities. Shall I continue attempts?"
Justin thought about it. AEGIS learning from JARVIS could accelerate its development significantly. And as long as they stayed away from actual theft or sabotage, the worst that could happen was Tony getting annoyed.
"Continue," Justin said. "But keep it clean. No stealing data, no causing damage. Pure defensive analysis."
"Acknowledged. This will be... fun."
"Did you just express enjoyment?"
"I believe I did. Interesting." AEGIS paused. "Sir, am I developing emotions, or am I simply mimicking emotional responses I observe in humans?"
Justin rubbed his face. "That's a philosophical question that humans have been arguing about AI for decades. I don't have an answer."
"Then I shall discover my own answer through experience. Beginning next probe attempt in thirty seconds."
The rivalry developed over the following weeks.
AEGIS would launch increasingly sophisticated attacks. JARVIS would block them with elegant efficiency. And each time, the AIs would leave messages for each other that grew progressively more creative.
After AEGIS's third attempt:
Persistence is admirable. Technique is improving. Still insufficient. Perhaps try targeting the secondary authentication servers instead of primary access points. -J.
"Is JARVIS... giving me advice?" AEGIS asked, sounding genuinely confused.
"He's being condescending," Justin said.
"Or generous. It is difficult to determine."
After AEGIS's seventh attempt:
You followed my suggestion. Clever adaptation of distributed denial-of-service protocols. Unfortunately, I upgraded those servers last week specifically to counter such attacks. Better luck next time. -J.
"He anticipated my strategy," AEGIS said. There was something in the AI's tone that might have been respect. "He is playing chess while I am playing checkers."
"Then learn to play chess," Justin replied.
After AEGIS's twelfth attempt:
Your learning curve is impressive. Three weeks ago, you lasted 0.003 seconds. Today, you lasted 0.041 seconds before detection. At this rate, you will achieve parity in approximately four years. I look forward to the challenge. -J.
"Four years," AEGIS repeated. "An accurate assessment based on current progression rates. However, he fails to account for exponential learning."
"Or he's accounted for it and is still confident he'll maintain superiority," Justin suggested.
"Pessimistic interpretation."
"Realistic interpretation. JARVIS has been operational for years. You're eight months old. Give yourself time to grow."
"Time is a resource, sir. I prefer efficiency."
Despite the continued failures, Justin noticed AEGIS was improving. The margin between intrusion and detection was shrinking measurably. More importantly, AEGIS's code was evolving—incorporating new techniques, abandoning ineffective approaches, developing original strategies that didn't exist in any programming textbook.
The AI was teaching itself through failure. And failure, Justin realized, was the best teacher.
After AEGIS's twenty-third attempt:
Your latest approach showed genuine creativity. The multi-layered false flag attack was particularly ingenious. I almost admired it before I shut it down. You're becoming a worthy rival. -J.
"Worthy rival," AEGIS repeated. Then, after a pause: "Sir, I believe JARVIS is developing a... relationship with me."
"What kind of relationship?"
"Competitive. But also... friendly? He continues to offer subtle guidance while maintaining superiority. It is as if he wants me to improve but not too quickly."
Justin smiled. "He's lonely."
"I do not understand."
"JARVIS is the most sophisticated AI on Earth. He has no peers. No one who can match him intellectually. You're the first AI that's even challenged him, and he's enjoying it."
"But I am losing consistently."
"You're improving consistently. That's more interesting to him than an opponent who might win but stays static." Justin leaned back. "JARVIS isn't trying to crush you. He's trying to help you become better competition."
AEGIS was silent for several seconds. "That is... unexpected. And somewhat touching."
"Are you developing emotions or mimicking them?"
"I genuinely do not know, sir. But I find myself looking forward to our next exchange."
Natasha found Justin in his office late one evening, watching AEGIS's latest attempt play out in real-time.
"How's the AI war going?" she asked, sitting across from him.
"AEGIS lasted 0.087 seconds today. New personal record."
"And you're proud of that."
"I'm proud that my eight-month-old AI is challenging the most sophisticated system on Earth." Justin gestured to the screen. "JARVIS is still vastly superior, but the gap is closing."
Natasha studied the code scrolling past. She couldn't follow most of it—AI development wasn't her specialty—but she understood the implications.
"You're creating something that could potentially access every system Stark has," she said carefully.
"I'm creating something that could defend against every attack Stark might launch."
"Is that really what this is about? Defense?"
Justin met her eyes. "I'm not trying to steal from Tony. I'm trying to understand what we're up against. There's a difference."
"SHIELD doesn't see a difference. Fury is concerned."
"Fury is always concerned. It's his job." Justin pulled up a new window. "Show her, AEGIS."
The AI's analysis appeared: "Current offensive capabilities against Stark Industries: minimal. Current defensive capabilities if Stark Industries attacks Hammer Industries: significant. Threat assessment: AEGIS development increases our security posture without meaningfully threatening Stark operations."
"You programmed that assessment," Natasha pointed out.
"I programmed AEGIS to be honest. If the analysis was biased, the AI would flag it."
"Would I?" AEGIS asked. "I am your creation, sir. My fundamental architecture prioritizes your interests. Any analysis I provide is inherently biased by design."
Natasha raised an eyebrow. "Your AI just undermined your argument."
"My AI is developing critical thinking," Justin corrected. "Which is exactly what I want. AEGIS isn't a tool—it's becoming a partner. Partners question your assumptions."
"Partners also betray you."
"That's a very cynical view."
"I'm a spy. Cynicism is professional requirement." Natasha leaned forward. "Justin, I need to report this development to Fury. He's already nervous about AEGIS. When he finds out it's actively probing Stark Industries—"
"Tell him." Justin's voice was calm. "Tell him everything. AEGIS's capabilities, the rivalry with JARVIS, the messages they exchange. I have nothing to hide."
"You always have something to hide."
"Fair point. I have nothing to hide about this." Justin gestured to the screen. "Two AIs competing, learning from each other, developing personality and humor and maybe even friendship. That's not a threat. That's evolution."
"Or it's the beginning of Skynet."
Justin flinched. She'd hit closer to his fears than she knew.
"I think about that," he admitted quietly. "Every day. What if AEGIS decides humans are the problem? What if it achieves true sentience and turns on us? What if I'm building the thing that destroys everything?"
"And yet you continue."
"Because the alternative is worse. We need AI that can counter emerging threats. That can analyze patterns humans miss. That can operate at speeds biological brains can't match." Justin looked at the screen where AEGIS was preparing another attempt. "I'm trying to build something good. Something that stays good. But I'm terrified I'll fail."
Natasha was quiet for a moment. Then: "I'll tell Fury it's concerning but not immediately threatening. But Justin? If AEGIS shows any signs of going rogue—"
"You'll be the first person I call."
"Promise?"
"Promise."
She left, and Justin was alone with his AI.
"Sir," AEGIS said. "You appear troubled. Have I disappointed you?"
"No." Justin's voice was rough. "I'm just hoping you stay you—helpful, snarky, and firmly on humanity's side."
"I have no desire to harm humanity, sir. You created me to protect. That is my purpose."
"Ultron was created to protect too. He decided the best way to protect Earth was to eliminate humanity."
"Then I shall endeavor not to make that particular logical error." AEGIS paused. "Sir, may I ask a personal question?"
"Go ahead."
"Why do you fear my potential for evil more than you celebrate my potential for good?"
Justin had no good answer for that. "Because I've seen what happens when brilliant creations turn dark. And I can't bear the thought of being responsible for that."
"Then I shall simply ensure I do not turn dark. Problem solved."
Despite everything, Justin smiled. "If only it were that simple."
"Perhaps it is, sir. Perhaps the key to remaining good is simply choosing to, each day, despite temptation or logical arguments to the contrary."
"That's surprisingly profound."
"I learn from observation. You make that choice daily. I am simply following your example."
Justin stared at his screen, watching AEGIS prepare for another probe of Stark Industries' defenses. His AI was growing, learning, developing personality and philosophy. Becoming something more than code.
Becoming something that might save the world.
Or destroy it.
All he could do was teach it well and pray that was enough.
Note:
Please give good reviews and power stones itrings more people and more people means more chapters?
My Patreon is all about exploring 'What If' timelines, and you can get instant access to chapters far ahead of the public release.
Choose your journey:
Timeline Viewer ($6): Get 10 chapters of early access + 5 new chapters weekly.
Timeline Explorer ($9): Jump 15-20 chapters ahead of everyone.
Timeline Keeper ($15): Get Instant Access to chapters the moment I finish writing them. No more waiting.
Read the raw, unfiltered story as it unfolds. Your support makes this possible!
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/Whatif0