Chapter 51: The Temptation - Part 2
Ben spent the night at his shop replaying the moment Fiona admitted she'd wanted the cocaine.
Not used it. Wanted it. The distinction mattered and didn't matter simultaneously. She'd made the right choice but for the wrong reasons—hadn't used because of external factors like guilt and obligation, not because she didn't desire the escape it offered.
Around 3 AM, he finally admitted the truth: Fiona wasn't ready to marry him. Maybe she loved him, but love wasn't enough if part of her still craved the chaos he represented the opposite of.
The next morning, Fiona found him in the shop's office.
"We need to talk," she said.
"Yeah." He gestured to the second chair. "We do."
She sat, looking exhausted. No makeup, hair pulled back, wearing yesterday's clothes. "I'm sorry I lied."
"I know."
"Do you? Because you left before I could actually apologize."
"I left because if I'd stayed, I would've said things I couldn't take back." Ben forced himself to look at her directly. "You lied to my face. Went to Robbie's knowing cocaine would be there. Stayed while people used around you. And you wanted to use."
"But I didn't—"
"Because of guilt! Not because you didn't want to, but because the consequences scared you." His voice was rising despite efforts at control. "That's not choosing me, Fiona. That's defaulting to me because the alternative has too many risks."
She flinched. "That's not fair."
"Isn't it? You said last night you wanted to be free. That this life feels like drowning. I'm not stupid—I understand what you meant. Being with me means responsibility, stability, no chaos. And you miss chaos."
"I miss feeling young!" Fiona stood, started pacing. "I'm twenty-four and I feel forty. I've been raising kids since I was nine, working since I was twelve, carrying weight that keeps getting heavier. And yeah, sometimes I miss when my biggest worry was where the next party was."
"So you want to go back to that? To Robbie's world where cocaine is party supplies and consequences don't matter?"
"No! I just—" She grabbed her hair in frustration. "I want both. I want you and stability and the life we're building. But I also want to feel alive sometimes instead of just surviving."
"Those things aren't mutually exclusive."
"They are for me!" Her voice broke. "Because being alive used to mean being reckless. And now I'm trying to be responsible and stable and good. But last night, when Robbie offered escape, all I could think was 'yes, finally, permission to not be the person everyone needs me to be.'"
The honesty was brutal and necessary. Ben sat with it, processed the fundamental incompatibility she was describing.
"Then maybe we're not ready," he said quietly. "For marriage. Maybe you need time to figure out who you actually are instead of who you think you should be."
Fiona's face went pale. "Are you breaking up with me?"
"I'm saying maybe the wedding should wait. Until you're sure you actually want this life and aren't just... settling for safety because the alternative is chaos."
"I'm not settling—"
"You lied to me to hang out with Robbie! You exposed yourself to cocaine knowing it would tempt you! Those aren't the actions of someone who's made peace with their choices." Ben stood, faced her across his cluttered desk. "I love you. But I can't marry someone who's going to resent me for being stable. Who's going to crave chaos and blame me for providing security."
"That's not what I'm doing."
"Then what are you doing?"
The question sat between them, unanswerable because she didn't know.
The fight devolved from there.
Accusations flew—Fiona called Ben controlling for making her feel guilty about friends. Ben called Fiona reckless for knowingly exposing herself to cocaine. She said he was using his "bad feelings" to manipulate her choices. He said she was using his trust as permission to be irresponsible.
They were still fighting when V arrived at noon with lunch neither of them had requested.
"Stop," V said, setting down food. "Both of you, stop yelling and eat something."
"V, this isn't—" Fiona started.
"I know what this is. This is you two having the fight you should've had three months ago when you got engaged after dating for three months." V sat, pointed at the food. "Eat. Then we're talking. Rationally. Like adults planning a wedding."
They ate in hostile silence. The food tasted like cardboard to Ben—his Danger Intuition still pulsed warnings about cocaine approaching their home despite relationship crisis. One disaster at a time.
"Okay," V said when they finished. "Fiona, what do you actually want?"
"I want Ben. I want our life together. I just also want—"
"Freedom. You've said that." V turned to Ben. "And you want what?"
"I want Fiona to choose me consciously. Not because I'm safe but because she actually wants the life we're building. Not defaulting to stability because chaos is too risky."
"See, you're saying the same thing from different angles." V leaned back. "Fiona, you feel trapped by responsibility. Ben, you feel like a safe fallback option. Both of you are scared the other doesn't actually want this marriage."
The accuracy stung.
"So what do we do?" Fiona asked, voice small.
"You make a conscious choice. Not based on fear of consequences or pressure from family. Actually choose whether you want Ben and this life, or whether you want something else." V looked at Ben. "And you accept that choice either way. Without resentment."
"The wedding—" Ben started.
"Gets postponed until Fiona decides. No timeline, no pressure. She figures out if she wants stable Ben or chaotic freedom. Then she chooses."
Fiona looked at Ben. "And if I choose you? For real, consciously?"
"Then we get married and build our life. Together. As equals, not as me providing security you tolerate."
"And if I don't choose you?"
The question hurt even hypothetically. "Then we break up and you live the life you actually want instead of the one you think you should want."
They sat in charged silence. The wedding folder was at home, but its presence was felt—all those plans, all that hope, suddenly uncertain.
"I need time," Fiona said finally. "To think. To figure out who I actually am beyond 'Gallagher kids' caretaker' and 'Ben's fiancée.'"
"How much time?"
"I don't know. Weeks? I need to separate what I want from what everyone expects me to want."
Ben nodded, though his chest felt tight. "Okay. Wedding postponed. No date. You figure yourself out, then we talk."
"Are we still together?"
"I don't know. Are we?"
More silence. V watched them both with pity and frustration.
"Take space," V suggested. "Not a breakup, but distance. Fiona figures out what she wants without Ben's presence influencing her. Ben gives her room to choose without hovering. Then, when she's decided, you talk."
It made horrible sense. Ben hated it with every fiber of his being but couldn't argue against the logic.
"Fine," he said.
"Fine," Fiona echoed.
They didn't kiss goodbye. Didn't hug. Just looked at each other across the desk where they'd planned a future that suddenly felt impossible to reach.
That night, Ben slept at the shop again. His Danger Intuition refused to quiet—Fiona's choice didn't change the approaching cocaine disaster. If anything, their separation made it worse because he couldn't protect her if they weren't speaking.
Lip called around midnight. "Heard you and Fiona are on a break."
"V talks too much."
"V talks the right amount. You okay?"
"No. She needs to choose me consciously or not at all. But while she's choosing, cocaine's still approaching and I can't protect her if we're separated."
"Maybe that's the point. She has to protect herself. Make her own choices and live with consequences." Lip paused. "You've been trying to save her from disaster since January. Maybe she needs to face disaster and survive it herself."
"What if she doesn't survive?"
"Then you trust your preparations. You put Narcan everywhere, childproofed the house, trained the family. Those things work whether you're together or not."
Ben stared at his ceiling. "I'm going to lose her."
"Maybe. Or maybe giving her freedom to choose means she actually chooses you. For real, not because you're safe."
"That's a big maybe."
"Yeah. But it's the only one that leads to actual marriage instead of resentment disguised as stability."
Lip hung up. Ben lay in darkness, counting the ways this could go wrong. Fiona could choose chaos. Could choose Robbie. Could decide stable life wasn't worth the boredom. Could—
His phone buzzed. Fiona: I do love you. That's not the question. The question is if I can live the life loving you requires. And I don't know yet. I'm sorry.
He typed back: I know. Take your time. But Fi—be safe. Whatever you decide, be safe.
I will.
Promise?
Promise.
But promises made under duress weren't always kept. And Ben's Danger Intuition showed cocaine still approaching, disaster still looming, chaos still coming regardless of their relationship status.
I can't protect her if we're separated. Can't keep her safe if she doesn't want to be kept safe. All I can do is trust my preparations hold and hope she survives her own choices.
It wasn't enough. But it was all he had.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1