Just as Max had guessed, both Sophie and Emily could hear Natalie's moans. They first felt uncomfortable, especially Emily, but after a while, they sorted out their feelings.
Following this, they thought about how they also would have to serve Max sooner or later—even though Max hadn't clearly indicated his interest in Emily like he had in Sophie and Natalie, she, just like her daughters, was already aware of Max's interest in her for years now and seeing how Max was fucking Natalie, she knew her and Sophie's number would also come soon—and begin feeling a mixture of unease and strange excitement.
…
"Arrrggghhhhh~"
A stabbing pain shot through Natalie's body and nerves tensed when Max forced his thick cock in her poor little pussy and ruthlessly and greedily claimed her virginity. For a moment, she felt as if she was about to die and let out a loud, pained cry.
To her horror, not only Max did not let up and give her some time to recover, he instead made another thrust and forced his cock into her depths until their pubic bones were touching.
She let out another pained cry and began wiggling her hips to pull away, wanting to stop this pain.
Right then, she felt Max cup her face and lovingly kiss her closed eyelids and say in a gentle voice, "Shhh, it's alright, babygirl. The pain will go away soon. Just take deep breaths and try to relax, alright?"
Natalie opened her eyes, red from pain and tears, looked at him with an aggrieved look and said, "Big Brother… wu~ you are completely heartless and selfish! You don't care whether I feel pain or not, you only care about your pleasure."
Seeing her cry like this, Max felt bad. Then after a moment, he kissed her tears away and apologetically nodded, "You are right, babygirl. I'm indeed selfish."
"How about this… since I caused you pain, here, you do the same too." He said, putting his forearm on her lips, "Bite me as hard as you can."
Natalie glared at him and hesitation flickered in her eyes.
Her mind told her to endure this and forgive him as he was her family's sole provider and saviour, but the pain he caused her had made her angry. So, ignoring her better judgement, she grabbed his hand with her now free hand, opened her mouth and bit hard.
"Hiss!"
Max hissed in pain somewhat exaggeratedly. Natalie wasn't strong enough to cause him pain, especially when he had clenched his muscles a little, but he had to show that she was. At the same time, he activated the [Sharing] trait and shared his pain tolerance with her, so the pain she was feeling wouldn't bother as much and she would relax.
Natalie saw him hiss in pain and scrunch up his facial muscles and suddenly felt bad. Just as she was about to stop, she noticed she was no longer feeling as much pain and her eyes lit up.
'It's effective!'
So, despite feeling bad, she continued biting him but she was barely using half the strength.
Max couldn't help but smile warmly when he felt this. At the same time, he felt a little guilty.
…
After a while, Natalie stopped biting altogether, kissed the red bite mark and softly blew on it before saying, "Sorry, Big Brother. I-I shouldn't have—"
Before she could finish speaking, Max leaned down, kissed her forehead and said, "No, I'm sorry. I shouldn't have been so rough."
Seeing him apologise, Natalie felt her heart soften and the little bit of resentment that had formed in her heart melted away, leaving no trace.
She then smiled sweetly at him, raised her hand and caressed his face, "I forgive you, Big Brother. I know you like me a lot and weren't able to control your excitement."
Max kissed her palm and smiled at her, "I'm really blessed to have such an understanding little sister."
"Now, babygirl, if you aren't feeling too much pain, can I start moving?" He asked.
Immediately, panic and fear flashed in her beautiful eyes. While she wasn't feeling much pain now, the earlier tearing sensation was vivid in her mind.
"B-Big Brother, can't you w-wait a little longer?" She asked, her voice soft and trembling.
Max shook his head. If not for the fact that he didn't want her to hate him which would make their relationship unpleasant, he wouldn't have stopped just now either and would have continued fucking her.
So, now that she wasn't feeling as much pain, he would not delay his pleasure any longer.
"O-Okay then. Please be gentle, Big Brother." Natalie said and her body tensed.
'Fuck!' Max felt her already tight pussy clench even more around him and suppressed a moan. He then looked at her and said in a husky voice, "Babygirl, try to relax a little otherwise you would feel more pain."
Saying this, he didn't wait for her to relax and began to pull out slowly. As his cock rubbed against her soft throbbing flesh, he felt electric pleasure hitting his nerves.
Once he was halfway out of her, he thrust forward…
Slap!
Their thighs slapped against each other.
Ahnnggg~
Natalie had been biting her lower lip to hold back her moans, but when he suddenly thrust inside her, an overwhelming pleasure shot through her that easily suppressed the sting of pain she felt. Her breath hitched, her waist arched up and she threw her head back, her eyes glazing over as she let out a loud moan.
"Ahnnggg~"
"Fuck! You feel amazing around my cock, babygirl!" Max groaned, gritting his teeth. The pleasure was so good and so intense that he almost climaxed.
"Big Brother~ Haaa~ Big Brother~ You also feel good inside me~" To Max excitement, Natalie responded while moaning and taking deep breaths to fill her lungs with oxygen which sounded so sexy that his cock throbbed, stirring her insides.
Slap!
Max slowly withdrew out of her tight canal halfway again and then entered with swift, forceful thrust.
Ahhhnnggg~
Ohhhnn~
Both moaned and Max slowly pulled out of her, this time until only his glans were inside her and thrust back.
Slap!
Nnngghh~
Slap!
"Big Brotherrrrr~ Slow down a little. Ahhnnnggg~"
Slap!
"Ahhhnnnnggg~"
Though it was difficult because Natalie was clamping tightly around his cock, not letting him pull out or enter easily, Max slowly increased the speed of his thrusts and began fucking her freshly deflowered pussy with long, fast and hard strokes, the sounds of their flesh slapping and their pleasured moans and groans echoing in the room.