Film doesn't lie. But it can forget. In the developer's tray, images arrived that Alex knew he'd captured—until the shapes softened under the red light, the faces lost their definition, and the places he needed to see became negative space. There is nowhere safer for the truth than on paper, he'd thought; but some stories bleach themselves from emulsion and memory alike.
------------------------------------
The clock in the photography lab ticked toward two a.m.—or perhaps it was stuck, and he simply needed it to feel like time was passing. Alex wiped his palms on his jeans for the twentieth time before extracting the second roll from his bag. Digital wasn't reliable anymore, but film had a stubborn slowness he trusted. Film wouldn't just blink and forget. Negatives preserve. Or they're supposed to.
He had brought the backup camera out of gut instinct weeks before mailing the letter to Maya, loading cheap 35mm black and white, combing Blackstone's grounds for angles digital sensors might miss—a habit inherited from a grandfather who'd believed the world was truest where the light left a physical record. Light could not negotiate with memory the way a corrupted hard drive could.
Carefully, he clipped the wet negatives to the line, watching the chemical drips feather down into the ruby-darkness. He hunched over the tray, timer beside, his movement careful and mechanical, every step performed as he'd rehearsed since high school. The latent images bloomed as the paper drank their secrets—at first intact, solid as fact. Here, a corridor with an exit sign tilting like a warning. There, a cluster of nursing staff at the nurses' station, Harriet's badge number visible, Elijah's hand clutching that notebook of circles.
But even as each print began to resolve, a tension prickled at the back of Alex's neck. Shadows on the paper squirmed from the corners inward. His hands, sticky with developer, hovered over the print of the east wing stairs—he could see where his own reflection had ghosted in the window glass, behind the faint silhouette of the heavy-set orderly who'd stepped quickly aside just as Alex had taken the picture. Only now, as the print cleared, that impression melted away, leaving only light in places he remembered dark.
By the third print, the faces were blurring in front of his eyes—not the rough blur of a shaky hand, or the accidental movement that ruins a candid, but a strange "softening," as if somebody had skimmed a thumb over each survivor's features, the world rendering anonymous at the precise places he most needed evidence.
He cursed under his breath. "Not a chemical error. The bath's clean, the paper's fresh…" His voice sounded defiant at first, then as he repeated the steps—rinse, fix, agitate, rinse, dry—he felt himself working like a man washing a body, convinced the right ritual could resuscitate the truth.
The clearest print was the most ordinary. A corridor devoid of any human figure, sunlight angling through the window in a slow, cold stripe. The shadows fell where he remembered, the light diffused exactly as he'd seen. Yet, along the bottom edge, right where the emulsion finished, a broken circle and a ring of smaller circles pressed into the white border. At first, he thought it an accidental chemical spill, then realized with a dry-mouthed jolt: Elijah's symbol. Impossible to explain, yet there, in photographic relief.
He rinsed it three times, pinched it carefully by the corners to dry. "Come on," Alex muttered, "hold." He wanted the evidence to resist. He wanted proof that didn't vanish after a single shake.
Hours passed—he lost track, only aware that the world beyond the glass had gone from navy to slate to the orange bleed of sodium lamps. When he finally pinned the prints to the cork board, the smell of fixer thick on his hands, relief made him bold: Polaroids, 5x7s, all of it, squared out in a deliberate pattern. Faces, places, each labeled in pencil: Elijah—notes; Nurse Reeves—badge 1084; Mourner—East Stairs; South Corridor—time 3:17.
He made coffee in the shared lounge and returned in fifteen minutes to find the change. At the heart of each photo, a small disc of yellow had begun to form, the pulp turning the color of scraped bone. The center bleached outward in tangible time, palimpsest-like, until the oldest faces—a nurse he remembered from early interviews, the old porter who'd shown him the basement fuse box—became the absent center of each record, a ghostly erasure radiating toward the unblinking corners.
He panicked. Thumbed his phone, fingers slipping on the wet glass.
The scanner was ancient but functional. He laid the corridor print onto the glass, careful not to smudge the ring of circles. As the scanner's head traversed the photo, he counted each shallow pass—a habit now, counting out of superstition. The computer screen bloomed with the preview and then crashed as soon as he hit the button for final export. The software closed with an old error—"General Fault"—that made no reference to files or formats.
He tried again, laying down the photo of the Mourner—the strange, pale figure caught in the mirror of a window at dusk, her head bowed so her face refused the camera. The scanner stuttered, gasped, and forced its lamp shut, a hardware noise that rolled across the lab like a cough.
On the third try, he picked the scan of the empty hallway, light slanting just so. The scan completed, auto-saved itself as 0000.jpg without input. He opened the file: an empty hallway, vacant but for a small distortion in the corner where the image warped, as if the wall had started to breathe.
His sense of time began to warp, too. Had the scanner noise happened before? Was that clock ahead or behind? He caught flashes in the reflection of the darkroom window: sometimes his own face, sometimes a pale version that seemed a grade too washed-out, like a newspaper photo left in the sun. Moving, his reflection lagged—half a beat late, as if memory was being scrambled by some low, electrical drag, a signal sent through stone and returned slightly corrupted.
With every new print, new evidence, the process repeated: faces softened, centers paled to yellow, incidentally-placed circles crept into the margins, as if tagged by a hand too quick to catch.
Alex scrawled notes with a thick, reliable felt pen, tracing every fresh development as a ritual, each letter pressed deeper into paper:
"Blurring at print—witnesses only, rooms intact."
"Circle motif prints—index? Invitation?"
"Yellowing fastest on prints exposed to air."
After each entry, he typed the same thing in a text document. But when he hit save, the file defaulted not to BlkStoneEvidence, but to Untitled, then again to 0000.txt. The file truncated his words, leaving only the first line. When he re-opened, the rest was gone.
He reached for his recorder, thinking to narrate the process for himself as a proof. "This is Alex Winters. Third of October. Evidence log night session—" and hit record.
Room tone, nothing but a long, sustained hum through the air. The speaker played back something deeper: a watery slip of sound. The occasional thump: a pipe, or else something knocking, patient and distant, at recurring intervals.
He felt the phobia of old hospitals—the feeling that you've crept into a place not built for you. Alone in the glow, every nerve in his forearm told him he was being watched, not by a camera but by the building itself, or worse, by the silence strongest at the center of the light.
Desperate, he started attaching labels to his prints with masking tape, annotations like breadcrumbs: "SEE HERE: Elijah's mark. 3:17 - unaccounted time." He made a fresh cup of instant coffee, drank it without noticing flavor. When he came back, half an hour later, several tapes were curling at the corners, others had dropped off entirely, paper circles on the floor as if the evidence was being shed by the board itself.
He wrote again, pressing harder, the pressure etching into his thumb's pad: "DO NOT ERASE." It vanished overnight.
A wave of true helplessness—sorrow, then anger—washed over him. He wanted to smash the glass, burn the photos, anything that would disrupt the steady, indifferent process he was witnessing. As if on cue, a ripple spread across the surface of the developer tray, though Alex could swear the room had no drafts, the doors were sealed.
He swept a palm over the water: smooth, then not. Concentric rings pulsed outward from some invisible center. In the water, for just a heartbeat, he saw a ring of tiny circles matching Elijah's, then the pattern dissolved.
He was acutely aware of the artificial gravity the room imposed—the way the air seemed heavy, disinclined to leave. The only movement was at the clock's second hand. Yet his own reflection in the glass had begun to blur, his features drifting slightly out of register. In the deep lens, Alex's face appeared one tone too pale, lagging behind his actual gestures by a humiliating millisecond. He raised his hand; the face's hand followed a breath later.
He fled the darkroom, leaving the board and its palimpsests, the developer with its rings. On waking, he found his prints wilted, centers gone transparent, tape fallen. Two labels remained: BLA and DO N—half names, half warnings.
That night, he left a recorder in the lab. Playback: the room, empty, breathing, the steady hum of a world erasing itself.
When he went to reply to Maya, his email auto-filled the signature line with: —A
Underneath, the quoted text:
Some horrors are better lef—
[END OF CHAPTER]
Coming Up:
Alex's grasp of chronology deteriorates. He leaves himself reminders—calendar events, Post-its, voice memos—but each morning finds the record reset. Campus acquaintances forget him, directory listings lose his name, and "absent frames" appear even in his dreams. One night, following faint music through the hall, he finds a corridor that shouldn't exist, lined with blank picture frames. Inside one, a hand-carved circle, freshly gouged.