Perspective: Omniscient Fool
Date: February 8, 2018
Time: A little after 10:30 AM, give or take a dimension
Location: The 4D space
Part 1: The War That Was Lost
"Why?"
Icelynn asked it with her cheek still pressed to his chest.
The couch floated in the middle of the 4D space with nothing under it except, very far below, the whole world, turning slowly and small enough to cover with 1 hand.
"Before I answer that," Revenhart said, "tell me what 2013 was supposed to be."
"That's a cheap opening, Evren."
"It's the right one. Humor me."
He had picked that opening on purpose.
If she keeps reading him wrong, she'll try to kill him again, and this time he'll find out about her existence.
Icelynn sighed into his shirt.
Humor him? Ughh, fine.
Quick reminder before we go any further, since this chapter is about to get strange: I'm the 1 telling you this story.
Keep that in the back of your head, because later on, somebody in this room is going to notice me.
Icelynn leaned over the edge of the couch, reached down toward the little world turning beneath them, and spun it with 1 fingertip until the Asura Empire faced up. The whole empire was smaller than her nail.
"2013 was supposed to be the year this died," she said, and tapped it.
Let me translate, because these 2 talk in shorthand and you weren't in the room.
In 2013, the Asura Empire, the biggest human nation in the world, went to war against every other race at the same time: elves, demons, dragons, beastkin, Valerion and all.
Icelynn and Revenhart wanted Asura to lose, and lose so badly it never got up. They had nothing against humans.
Asura was simply the only nation big enough to stand between the elves and the demons and force them to sign a peace every time they got close to killing each other.
Take Asura off the map, and nobody is left to stop anyone.
"With the humans gone, nobody's left in the middle," Icelynn went on, and she sounded almost fond of it.
"The elves and the demons can go at it. By 2015 the border reopens, and this time there's no Asura standing between them playing referee, so nobody calls a peace. One of them gets wiped out, and the winner swallows what's left."
"You're skipping the ending again."
"I never skip the ending. The ending is the best part." She held up 2 fingers.
"A race that just swallowed another race is fat, tired and full of people who hate it. You feed it 15 years of uprisings, plagues, succession fights and border wars, and you do the same to every other race, one at a time, until there's only 1 throne left in the whole world and nobody strong enough to sit on it except us."
Us meaning him on the throne, and her standing right behind it, where she has always preferred to stand.
"Then why," Revenhart asked, "was 2013 the worst slaughter anyone alive can remember?"
Her fingertip stopped on the little empire.
"Because it happened to the wrong side," she said.
"Asura Empire won. It beat every race at once, Valerion included. We built that slaughter for the humans, and the Specter turned it around and pointed it at everyone else."
"Beaten by one boy with no magic."
"I know who won, Evren."
It came out flat and dead, and Revenhart smiled at the ceiling, because he had been waiting 5 years to hear her admit it out loud.
"You got so mad about losing," he said, "that you went and made the worst friends in the world."
Her whole body went still against his.
No... I wiped every log, every message, every—
"I don't know what you're talking about."
"Azrian. The cult of Nemesis. And every god on this planet except Malphas and Meldiz, all sitting at the same table for the 1st time in 7,000 years, agreeing on exactly 1 thing." He brushed a strand of hair off her forehead.
"Kill Celestara's reincarnation."
Icelynn sat up.
"Elfina Lunaris," Revenhart said.
"The Specter's goddess. Everyone at that table wanted her dead, and the one they really wanted to hit was him. Kill the girl he'd burn the world for, and the Specter breaks without anyone touching him."
"She was a THREAT, Evren."
"I know what she was."
"No, you don't! You were sitting in that chair reading for a whole year! She got stronger every single month! Do you know what she would've become? She was Celestara in a teenage girl's body, and the day she remembered that, Celestara would've come for us 1st. And the quill doesn't even work on her! What was I supposed to do, wait for you to finish chapter 9?"
"You were supposed to tell me."
"You'd have said no!"
"Probably..."
"Because you're a COWARD about this stuff! You forgive everyone, you understand everyone, and somebody has to actually do the—"
She stopped, because he wasn't arguing back, and Icelynn has never known what to do with someone who doesn't argue back.
"How long?" she asked.
"4 years."
"You've known for 4 YEARS and you never said a word?"
"No."
"Why not?!"
"Because I was waiting for a solution," Revenhart said, "and blaming you isn't one."
If you're keeping score at home: 4 years, 0 fights, 1 man sitting on the worst thing his partner ever did to him, because he wanted an answer more than he wanted to be right. I've watched a lot of couples, and I can count the ones who'd do that on 0 hands.
Icelynn opened her mouth, closed it, and looked away, which for her is the same as a full apology.
"It worked," she muttered. "She's gone. I succeeded."
"You did," he agreed. "And your success bought us a permanent enemy."
"He doesn't even know it was me."
"Yet. He'll find every hand that touched it, Icelynn, because that's what he does, and yours is on it." Revenhart sighed and let his head fall back against the couch.
"I wanted to recruit him."
"RECRUIT HIM!?"
"From what I've read... he wanted to save this world."
"HUH?! He's a psychopath, Evren!"
"Maybe so... Tell me about the jets incident again."
Oh, here we go.
"I gave you that report in 2014."
"And I read it 40 times." He held up a hand and counted on it.
"1. The engines sit behind an anti-mana barrier, so no mage, no dragon and no radar can feel them coming.
2. The flight computer flies faster than a pilot thinks, so the pilot only chooses the target and the jet does everything else.
3. The lock. It reads a dragon's wingbeat, calculates where the dragon is going to be, and fires at the soft scales over the heart-core, so 1 hit kills.
4. Mach 3."
"I know what's in my own report."
"Then tell me how they compare to the jets in your old world."
Icelynn chewed the inside of her cheek.
"Our best jets had computers that helped the pilot," she said finally.
"His don't need the pilot. Ours could lock onto a plane. His lock onto a living thing that can dodge, and still hit it in the heart. Ours had radar, and radar can be jammed. His use no mana or radio-waves at all, so there's nothing in this world that even knows how to jam them."
"So 3 times worse."
"So 3 times BETTER, Evren, that's my point, he took everything my world spent a century building and made it better without ANY EXPERIENCE, and I—"
She didn't finish that one either.
I could have built that... I would have built that, if I'd thought of it too.
Here is the thing nobody in this world knows about Icelynn, so I'll tell you.
She has never lost a war she planned. The only time she ever lost, she was betrayed and sealed in a black hole, and she excuses that under "trust," which is a different category from "intelligence."
Since then, nothing, until a kid with no magic built a better weapon than her home planet and broke her best plan in half.
Her hatred for him is real. But it's a by-product.
What she actually can't stand is the idea of being 2nd.
An inferiority complex from a goddess who has never lost in a war of deceit and strategy.
Part 2: What Writing Is
"So, I've been trying the quill," Revenhart said.
"On Kaiser? Without telling me?"
"You started a war this morning without telling me. We're even." He picked a book out of the air, The Specter, Volume 3, and opened it to a page he had folded down so many times the corner had gone soft.
"3 times, while he was at the Academy. The 1st time, I wrote that he climbs the highest tower at midnight and jumps. He went up at 11:58. At 11:59, Elfina came up the stairs with 2 cups of tea, because the day before, Kaiser had told her the view from that tower at midnight was the best thing in the whole Academy."
"Coincidence," Icelynn said immediately. "She was annoyingly clingy. You got unlucky."
"The 2nd time, I wrote that he swallows a bottle of rat poison... He swallowed all of it."
"However, he had swapped the powder for sugar 3 weeks earlier, and we don't know why."
"Then he's crazy. Crazy people do crazy things, Evren, that's not genius."
"The 3rd time, I wrote that he will commit suicide by drowning. He walked up to the river, and a fisherman pulled him out by the collar. 1 month earlier, somebody paid that fisherman a full season's wages to sit at that exact position every evening, in case anybody fell in."
Icelynn opened her mouth to say coincidence again and found she didn't have it in her anymore.
"Who paid him?"
"Kaiser. Under a fake name called 'Wizner'."
1 is luck. 2 is crazy. 3 is a man who knew exactly where the river was going to want him.
"He prepared for a death I hadn't written yet," Revenhart said, and closed the book.
"That's beyond anticipation. He prepares for doom that doesn't even exist, every single day, in case it ever does."
"Who even lives with that in their head every day?"
"Somebody who's outlived a lot of people who wanted him dead." Revenhart tossed Volume 3 back into the orbit. "So either my quill is broken, or I never understood what it actually edits. It isn't broken. Last week I wrote that a merchant in Vaelcrest sells his shop to his brother, and he did it the next morning, word for word."
"Then it edits people," Icelynn said. "Obviously."
"Does it?" He pulled the Meldiz book down out of the orbit, the 1 whose back page had written itself that morning, and dropped it in her lap. "Elfaria wrote this about a real person. Is that Meldiz?"
"It's a book about Meldiz."
"Right. It's a version of him. Read it and tell me what that version is made of."
Get comfortable. This next part is where your brain does push-ups, and I promise to count for you.
Icelynn flipped through the book at the speed of a woman who intends to prove someone wrong in under a minute, and then she slowed down.
"Fine, Elfaria wrote the book about Meldiz," she said.
"Meldiz is in here, obviously. Her opinions are in here too, she drew him with sparkles. There are dragon customs, old songs, that whole thing about fire being sacred, stuff no single person ever invented. And the reasons under everything, why he is prideful, why he's scared now. Characters, the writer's philosophy, a whole culture's wisdom, psychology. Happy?"
"Very," Revenhart said. "Because that's what the quill edits. A version of somebody, built out of those things. When I write a person's fate, I'm editing their book. Remember that, it's the whole trick." He nodded at the page. "And there's 1 more thing inside every book. Turn to the back."
She turned past Elfaria's last chapter to the page that had written itself earlier, the 1 she had already read over his shoulder.
At 11:40 AM, Queen Rishie summoned her generals.
"I've seen this 1," she said. "So the book keeps up with the news. Cute."
"Turn again."
There were 2 more pages after it now, and neither of them had been there an hour ago.
She read the 1st out loud, and it didn't sound like Elfaria at all.
There were no emojis, no bouncing and no exclamation marks, only a calm, flat voice that belonged to nobody.
The man the queen keeps asleep in the east wing will open his eyes soon, and when he does, the kingdom will not keep the shape it has today.
Icelynn stopped breathing.
"Axel?"
"Elfaria," Revenhart called, without looking away from her. "Did you write that?"
"Nope! 🙅♀️ Not me! I would've drawn a cute little dragon at the bottom! 🐉"
"I didn't either," he said. "And neither did you."
"Obviously I didn't, I want him asleep."
Here's what Icelynn understood just then, readers, and it went through her cold.
That book was never only about Meldiz. It was a living record of the dragons and everything tied to them, and it had just updated itself, all on its own, with a future nobody in this room had planned.
Axel was going to wake up, Raphaelis was going to change, and the war Icelynn had started that morning ran straight through Raphaelis.
It's predicting my war.
"Turn the last 1," Revenhart said quietly.
She did. The last page started in the same calm voice and then fell apart halfway down, the letters crawling, doubling and breaking off in the middle of words:
and after he wakes the dragons fl— fly— fall and the queen's heart the queen's action ink action 7 crowns 0 crowns 1 crow— the sia breaks before the wi— before— befo▓▓ who is read— who is reading wh— ▓▓▓▓ ▓ ▓▓
The last line stopped in the middle of a letter, and the rest of the page stayed white.
"What the hell is that?"
"That's the future running out of certainty." Revenhart took the book from her lap and held it open between them.
"Only the quill can write the future, Icelynn. Nothing else can, not Elfaria, not the gods, not this book. Everything else can only read what's already true and guess forward from it. Up close, it's sure: Axel wakes. Further out, fate isn't settled yet, so the guesses come apart."
"So the book's a Reader."
"Exactly. It's reading this story. It reads everything Elfaria ever fed it and everything happening right now, and then it narrates what's coming in a voice that isn't hers. That's the neutral voice. Every book has one. It's whatever's still talking after you take the writer out."
Something in her face went sharp and interested, which on her is the most dangerous expression in any dimension.
She tapped chapter 9.
"Alright, imagine Elfaria wrote this to make me cry for that lizard," she said slowly.
"I read it and decided he's an idiot. She'll swear he's tragic until the day she runs out of tokens, and it doesn't matter, because I'm the one holding the book." She looked up.
"As such I decided my own meaning from the book."
"The reader wins. Elfaria's meaning died the second she handed it over."
"The author dies," Revenhart said, "so the reader can be born. Hold on to that. Readers decide who somebody is, and it matters in about 5 minutes."
"That's Barthes."
"Who?" Revenhart asked.
"Ughh. Just some French guy from my world. He wrote almost exactly that, about 70 years before I died."
"Then I'm in good company," he said happily, "and a little less crazy."
"That part's still debatable."
"Then here's a piece he didn't have," Revenhart said.
"Do you know why I stopped being Kaiser Revenhart?"
That got her attention, because he had never explained it out loud before properly, and because she tries very hard not to think about the fact that the psycho in Sylvaris answers to the same 1st name.
"A name is a representation," he said.
"A name on a book is how the world knows the character to blame for it, and a name on a person works the same way. Kaiser meant hope, and humanity, and a crown for people who never had one. Every time somebody needed a symbol, they grabbed me by that representation and pulled, and every time something went wrong, that representation was how they found me to blame. When you rebuilt me, the name was still lying there with 7,000 years of other people's hopes on it, so I left it on the floor and picked one nobody had ever hoped anything from."
So that's why... Not only because of his father but destroying that representation.
"And the Author," he went on, "the real capital-A kind, is a person who lives before the book. He plans it, suffers for it and finishes it, and from then on he's stuck to it forever. That's me. An Author can be rewritten, because everything he is was finished a long time ago."
"Then the quill could rewrite you."
"Somebody already rewrote my fate."
Icelynn looked away.
Idiot. Don't make that face at me.
"So Kaiser's the opposite," she said, a little too fast. "He doesn't live a plan you can read and then edit. He decides as he goes. You wrote the tower for midnight, and he'd already changed that night the day before. Your sentence was about a version of him that was already gone."
Revenhart's smile widened. "At least that. We'll get there."
He set the Meldiz book back into the orbit. "Now the audience—"
"Let me guess," Icelynn cut in. "Readers are cowards. They cry over Meldiz, close the book, eat dinner and risk nothing. Every feeling, zero cost."
"That's the deal," he agreed.
"When Celestine threw the Specter a parade, half that crowd had cried over the war for a week, and then they went home and forgot every soldier who was in it. They watched the war and never had to be in it. Until the deal breaks, and the reader gets dragged onto the page, and he stops watching and starts experiencing its trauma."
He looked down at her.
"You know exactly what that's like."
"I don't cry at books, so no."
"You read stories in your old world," Revenhart said quietly. "You told me. And then you woke up 5 years old in a gutter in somebody else's story. Your audience died that morning, Icelynn."
She didn't answer.
I've watched her for a very long time, readers.
She has an answer for everything, for impossibility and even for Elfaria at her most annoying.
I have never, not one time, seen her run out of answers.
"Then is Kaiser a transmigrator too?" she asked after a while. "Like me? Did somebody drag him in from somewhere else?"
"No. He was born in this world, and nobody dragged him anywhere. That's the part that scares me." Revenhart's voice stayed quiet.
"You had to be thrown onto the page to stop being a Reader. He stopped on his own. He read this world for years, worked out that he was standing inside a story, and stepped onto the page with his eyes open. He's moved past the rank of a Reader, Icelynn, and he did it without ever leaving home."
Ohhh this is getting exciting...
Before you get confused let me help you out.
Basically, once an author puts a story out there, their opinion doesn't matter anymore because the reader takes total control of what it all means. Being just a reader is a pretty sweet, zero-risk gig where you get to feel all the drama from the sidelines and still close the book to go eat dinner whenever you want.
A reader only stops being a reader when that safe little bubble pops and they actually have to live through the story's trauma instead of just watching it. That happens either by getting rudely pulled into the plot like Icelynn, or by realizing your whole world is fated and choosing to step onto the page yourself so nobody can predict or rewrite your next move, just like Kaiser did.
Part 3: Multiple Kaisers
"Then why doesn't the quill work on the gods?" Icelynn asked. "Or Azrian. Or Elfina. If you're so smart."
"Start with a word," Revenhart said.
"You call him the psycho. A demon soldier in Pandemonium calls him the Specter and means the monster that killed his brother. To a Celestine farmer it means the hero who brought the children home. To a girl at the Academy it means a historical figure. 4 continents use the same word, and none of them mean the same person. A word means whatever the people using it agree it means, and that's all it ever means."
"Wow, a linguistics lesson. Skip to the part where it's useful."
"So when the whole world agrees on a title, the title gets bigger than the person under it. Celestine threw the Specter a parade, and he wasn't even invited. People cheer the title and forget the person."
"Great, so people are shallow. The gods, Evren."
"Gods are the biggest titles there are." He leaned back.
"Take Celestara. A farmer prays to her as a mother. A soldier prays to her as a judge. A priest prays to her as a law. A widow prays to her as the 1 who took her husband and owes her an answer. That's millions of people, and every single 1 of them holds a different Celestara in their head, and they're all certain theirs is the real one."
"So belief is protection? That's a priest's argument, Evren."
"It's a math argument. The quill writes 1 meaning. I write 'Celestara is weak,' and 10 million readers are holding 10 million different Celestaras, and not one of them agrees with my page. 1 quill can't outvote a world."
Icelynn's eyes narrowed. "That's my theory of gods."
Dang Icelynn let him COOK!
"It is," he said, pleased. "Attention, Anchor, Witness. I just turned it around. The same thing that feeds a god is what makes the quill bounce off it. And Elfina was a little goddess, so she had it too."
"Fine, gods. Rose Valentine isn't a god, and the quill slides off her too."
"To change someone, the quill has to describe them 1st. Rose has curse magic, which says she's cursed, and celestial magic, which says she's the opposite. The quill can't describe her without contradicting itself, so it can't edit her."
"And Azrian? He's the coward cult leader."
"Azrian is a Singularity. In Ceres Omega, the Void renamed him on its own. Nobody believed him into that name, and nobody wrote a book about it. The story itself wrote him. The quill can edit a version of somebody, but Azrian isn't a version, he's the original." He shrugged.
"Some of his people are covered through his blessing, and a lot of others can blunt the quill a little."
"So here's the rule," he said, and counted it off plainly.
"1. The quill edits the one version of you that people agree on.
2. Gods have millions of versions, so there's no single 1 to edit.
3. Rose's version contradicts itself, so there's nothing to edit.
4. The story wrote Azrian directly, so he isn't a version at all.
5. Everyone else has one version, one book, and the quill can touch them."
"Everyone else?"
"Consider them as readers."
Here it comes.
"Hold on." Icelynn held up a hand before he could start. "You said 'Specter' means a different person on 4 continents. Millions of people, millions of Specters. By your own rule, that's god math. That's why the quill misses him?"
Revenhart beamed at her.
Good. She's arguing with it instead of calling me crazy.
"That's the 1st thing I checked," he said. "The Specter, maybe. But I never wrote 'the Specter.' I wrote 'Kaiser Everhart,' a student from the Asura Academy about 30 people in the world have heard of. 30 readers can't outvote my singularity."
"So it isn't God math."
"No. That's what kept me up at night for the past 2 years."
Icelynn's jaw tightened. "Then he's not a god. He's not a Singularity, he's not an anomaly, he has no magic, no gift, no blessing, nothing..."
"So why doesn't the quill work on him?"
Before Icelynn answers... Let me simplify it for you cause I'm just sooooo kind!! 💖
Basically, a word or a name only means whatever people collectively agree it means, and the quill changes reality by editing that single agreed-upon version of a person or reality.
You can dodge the quill if millions of people hold completely different versions of you in their heads like the Gods, if your conflicting powers make you impossible to describe without a contradiction like Rose, or if the universe itself named you directly like Azrian.
Because the quill only writes one meaning at a time, it simply cannot outvote millions of minds, resolve a logical paradox, or overwrite someone who has no secondary version to edit.
That logic makes Kaiser a complete mystery, because barely 30 people know his real name and he has none of those protections, yet the quill still fails to touch him.
"Because he's a suicidal psycho who—"
"That's your book," Revenhart said gently.
"What?"
"'Suicidal psycho.' That's the book you wrote about him in your head. It's a good book. It's short, it's easy to hate, and you finished it in 2013 and you've been rereading it ever since. But it's your version. It's the Kaiser you need him to be, so you can stay angry at him."
"It's an ACCURATE version."
"Then explain the zoo."
Icelynn's jaw worked, and nothing came out of it.
"Explain this," Revenhart went on, tapping 1 volume after another.
"He could be the richest man on the continent by next month, yet he refuses wealth. He was a heartless killer in 2013, and he's kind to strangers in 2018, for free, when no one's watching. He begs outside a church and gives the coins away. He lives in Sylvaris doing nothing and has more information than the Celestine crown. He's 2 people at once, all the time."
"Okay, but—"
"And then there's the big one." His face went completely serious.
"Have you heard about his smut?"
Icelynn froze.
"How do YOU know about that?"
"Elfaria told me."
"ELFARIA!"
"Delivered 50 minutes ago! 📬✨" came a cheerful voice from 2 directions over. "Hehe, I'm loyal! 🤭"
"Book 4," Revenhart said, ignoring both of them, "chapter 2."
He held out his hand, and The Specter, Volume 4 flew into it.
"Elfaria spent a year on this chapter. 41 documented attempts by the Academy's most beautiful girls to seduce him. Love letters, staged accidents, and opportunities for pleasure. She tracked his records by fruit flies. Never has he revealed himself over pleasure. This chapter proves, with every method and every scrap of data she had, that no woman has ever seduced Kaiser Everhart."
"Data's airtight! 📊 I triple-checked! 💯"
"And last night," Revenhart said, "he walked into a back-alley shop and bought 4 books written purely for lust."
He let that sit.
"He contradicts his own contradictions, Icelynn. Every time Elfaria proves who he is, he goes and becomes somebody else. That's why there are 7 books. She wrote one Kaiser, he broke it. She wrote another, he broke that too."
"So he's inconsistent.... People are inconsistent."
"People are inconsistent in one direction. You can predict a liar, because he lies. You can predict a coward, because he runs. Kaiser is inconsistent in every direction at once, so there isn't one Kaiser for anyone to point at."
And now, readers, watch his voice.
It's going to get quieter, and his sentences are going to get shorter, because this is the part he's been carrying the longest.
"The quill needs 1 version of you to edit," Revenhart said.
"Most people have one. They pick who they are and stay that person, because it's easier, and the moment everyone agrees who you are, there's a version the quill can grab. Kaiser never lets anyone finish deciding who he is."
He opened all 7 volumes together, and they hung in the air around the couch in a ring.
"7 Kaisers on 1 page. Fate comes looking and finds 7. It has to pick 1. Whichever it picks, he's standing somewhere else."
The 7 books turned slowly around them.
"That took me 4 years. Do you know how I finally got it? I stopped reading 1 book about him and read all 7 side by side. Each 1 got part of him right and the rest wrong, and no 2 of them agreed. There isn't one version of Kaiser anywhere for the quill to accurately rewrite."
Icelynn looked at the 7 books for a long time.
No... He has no gift. He has nothing. He can't just... think his way out of fate... That's not a thing a person does.
That's a thing I do... He's not special...
"You're making a mistake," Revenhart said softly, "treating him as an ordinary character."
It hit her somewhere under the ribs, and she hated that it hit.
"I don't treat him as anything," Icelynn snapped. "I treat him..."
"Answer it Icelynn."
Look at how completely speechless Icelynn gets in this scene, readers, because Revenhart just tore apart the exact way she views Kaiser.
Philosophically, Revenhart proves that determinism and the quill only control you when you maintain a fixed identity and behave in a predictable pattern that observers/readers can define. While Icelynn clings to a single angry label for Kaiser, Kaiser constantly acts against his own established traits and destroys every logical category that Elfaria and the world put him in.
By refusing to maintain a static personality and constantly contradicting himself, Kaiser prevents anyone from forming one complete, accurate definition of who he is, which leaves fate and the quill with no stable target to rewrite.
Nobody understands his complexity, not even the readers, not even the author.
Part 4: The Dreamer
She got off his lap, which she only does when she needs to pace, and paced.
"Fine! Say I buy it. Say he's a walking contradiction and fate can't rewrite him. That still doesn't explain the page," she said, pointing at the Meldiz book drifting by.
"Something is reading ahead of us! Kaiser is in Sylvaris reading smut magazines while AXEL is SEAS AND CONTINENTS AWAY!"
"Something knew Axel was waking before I did and it ISN'T KAISER! If the neutral voice keeps talking after the writer's gone, then whose voice is it?!"
Revenhart grinned, wide and delighted.
"There she is."
"Don't 'there she is' me, answer the question."
"Imagine somebody who hates their life," he said, leaning forward with his elbows on his knees.
"Their real life is small. Boring, painful, whatever. So they dream, and in the dream they build a person. A heart 1st, out of whatever they wish they had. Then a body, then a soul, then a personality, the way they talk, the way they walk into a room. Then they send that person out into a world to live the life they couldn't, and every real thing that person feels, the dreamer gets to keep."
"That's a novel," Icelynn said. "You just described a novel. On Earth I used to read until 4 in the morning because the people in books had better lives than me." She stopped pacing.
"So I was a dreamer. Fine. What's the bad part?"
"The bad part is that the dreamer thinks they're the top. They're the one holding the dream, so they must be the real one. What they haven't realized is that the nightmare is the knowledge itself. If they can dream a person into a world, then the world they're sitting in could be somebody else's dream, and that somebody could be dreamt by somebody else."
"That's infinite regress," Icelynn shot back. "Every 1st-year student learns to throw that out on day 1, because it never ends anywhere."
"It ends somewhere worse. The worst version is that the dreamer is being dreamt by another dreamer that lives inside the dreamer itself." He spread his hands.
"Every time I find a creator, he turns out to be made of somebody older. Every time I climb to the highest level, it bends around and drops me back at the bottom. There's no 1st page. There are only texts that describe the lack of existence of the author."
"That's metaphysics, Evren. Can you prove any of this?"
"It's metafiction. A story about the people inside a story, finding out they're inside a story." He tilted his head.
"Want me to prove it with something you can touch?"
"Please. Something I can touch would make a nice change."
He had rehearsed this part for weeks, and then thrown the rehearsal away.
"Who brought me back?"
That 1 landed in the room and stayed there.
"I was gone," Revenhart said, very lightly, without looking at her.
"Asora burned the soul. There was nothing left to bring back. So you took Elfaria's memories of me and every scrap of history the world forgot to erase, and you built a man out of them. A heart 1st, from what she remembered I cared about. Then a 21-year-old robotic body, from nobody's memory at all. Then the way I talk, the way I sit, the way I tilt my head when I'm thinking."
"Evren."
"And then you sent me back out into a world to live a life I'd already lost. You're my dreamer, Icelynn. And the memories you built me from came from my own life, which means I made the material you used to make me. So where does the story start?"
She didn't move. Even Elfaria, somewhere in the 5th direction, had stopped bouncing.
"You're kind of crazy," Icelynn said at last, and her voice wobbled only very slightly.
"But you're making sense, and I hate it... My world had a name for this. The simulation hypothesis. Some scientists thought the whole universe might be running on somebody else's computer, and there'd be no way for us to tell from the inside."
"Same idea with a scientific name. A dreamer with a computer instead of imagination."
"Except the computer is supposed to be the scientific version."
"The computer is the version that makes scientists feel better," he said, and she threw a cushion at him, which he caught.
Using dreamer logic, he explains that anyone who creates or imagines a character assumes they sit at the top of reality, when in truth their own world could easily be the creation of another dreamer, or even a closed loop where the creation and the creator make each other.
That brings them straight into metafiction, where the characters inside a narrative realize they are fictional and discover there is no ultimate, original author outside the text at all.
Revenhart proves this loop is real by pointing out that after he died, Icelynn rebuilt him out of the memories and history he originally left behind, meaning he created the exact material she used to create him, so neither of them is the true beginning of the story.
She was pretending to be more confused than she was. You noticed that, right?
Good. She can follow every step of this, and she's choosing to look lost, because if she admits she follows it, then she has to admit the magicless boy might have followed it 1st.
"So who dreamt me?" Icelynn asked, more quietly than she meant to.
"That's the question I was hoping you'd ask." Revenhart set the cushion down. "You don't know who transmigrated you."
"No."
"You never asked."
"I was 5 in an unknown world, I was busy rebuilding civilization."
"Think about it now, then. Of all the souls in your world, somebody picked yours. A genius. A God. The kind of mind that could, 250 years later, build a dead man out of memories and a quill." He let her catch up. "I think somebody sent you here for me. Specifically you, so that even after I died, I could still do something."
"That's a terrible plan. That plan has 1,000 ways to fail."
"It's a gamble. A good one, though. It worked." He tapped his own chest.
"And if somebody gambled on one transmigrator, they gambled on more. We just haven't met them."
"Or we already have," said Icelynn, and her head came up sharply.
"Elfaria," Revenhart said. "Show her."
"Ready! 🫡" A panel unfolded in front of them, showing a gray, folded slice of something under glass.
"Remember the weird memory gaps in the Pandemonium dockworkers last month? 🤔 We grabbed 1, ran tests, and found these in his brain! 🧠🪱 Parasites! And look at their wiring! 🔌"
Icelynn leaned in, and then leaned in further.
"That's my chip! WHAT THE HELL?!"
"It's your chip's architecture, but grown out of something alive," Revenhart said. "Somebody stole your design and grew it using magic instead of building it with science."
"Azrian couldn't do that! Azrian couldn't decode my chips if I printed him instructions!"
"No, he couldn't. Azrian is very smart, but he isn't a scientist. Somebody is helping him who is..."
"The Evernight Woman," Icelynn breathed.
"The mastermind behind the cult, she had grown mind-control parasites out of your stolen design, and signed them with his name on his crates." Revenhart smiled thinly.
"I don't know who she is. But I'd bet the quill she wasn't born in this world either."
Ohhhh so Azrian too has a transmigrated waifu? ✍️🔥
Part 5: The Narrative Ladder
"Alright," Icelynn said, sitting back down, this time next to him instead of on him, which tells you she was thinking very hard. "Give me the whole thing. You've been feeding me crumbs."
"I do, but you'd hate it as a list." Revenhart reached into the orbit and pulled down a thin, battered book with no title on the spine.
"So I'll tell it as me."
Icelynn knew that book. She had read it 300 times the year she rebuilt him, 1 page at a time.
"Elfaria's book about you."
"The material you built me from." He opened it near the front and rested it on his knee.
"There's a ladder in here. I didn't see it until this year. It has nothing to do with power. It measures how much you understand about the story you're standing in, and what you understand decides what the story can do to you."
He tapped the 1st chapter.
"Here I'm 12. A village hiding from the other races, a father, mother and sister, and no idea the world has a purpose. I knew what was written for me: Raise the next generation. That's RANK 8, the Reader. Most of the planet lives there."
"And they're happier than either of us," Icelynn said.
"Much happier." He turned a handful of pages, past a chapter he didn't stop to read, and she didn't ask him to.
"Then Azrael came to the village. After that I knew I'd never beat a demon general with my hands. No mana, no gift. So I stopped trying to fight the gods head to head and started building scientific tools instead. That's RANK 7, the Listener. Born with enough talent to change the world, smart enough to know you'd lose a fair fight, so you improvise."
"That's when you started building the machines that eventually heard me."
"That's when." He turned more pages.
"Then one night I worked out that the people I was saving were going to kill me for it. My existence was the threat, so I started counting threats before they arrived. RANK 6, the Character. Someone who knows the story wants them gone, and reads ahead."
"And you still died."
"I read ahead. I didn't read far enough." He laid a finger on the page, gently.
"This is where Kaiser is. RANK 6. And he's already immune to me."
Icelynn thought about that, and did not enjoy it.
"The Savior years," Revenhart went on, turning again. "I quit planning my life and started writing it while I lived it. Every speech made up on the stairs, every miracle improvised the same morning. RANK 5, the Scriptor. You can bend some of fate that way, just by refusing to wait for it."
"Your messages from those years were insufferable."
"They were very confident."
"They had fullstops, Evren."
He laughed and turned 1 more page, and kept turning, and frowned.
"RANK 4 isn't in here. A Weaver takes ideas from 100 cultures and 100 old stories and braids them together until even fated things start to move. Celestara did it with faith. Azrian does it with cults and kidney touching acting. I never did."
"Azrian's a Weaver? Never tell him that. He'll make it his whole personality." She leaned over the book.
"And you can't skip a RANK."
"You can if somebody hands you a quill." He turned to the last page with writing on it.
"Dead at 31, rewritten by you, holding the quill."
"RANK 3, the Author, the ones who writes fate's future. That's me."
"Modest."
"Borrowed," he corrected. "I climbed from 8 to 5 on my own and got carried over 4. Maybe that's why it doesn't work on him. I'm an Author who skipped the part where you learn how stories are woven."
Icelynn didn't have a comeback for that, which was turning into a pattern she disliked.
He turned the page after that, and it was blank. So was the next, and the 1 after it.
"After this, nobody I know has been," he said. "RANK 2, the Dreamer, who dreams the Author while he writes. RANK 1, the Unwritten, who never even wrote the Dreamer, only pictured him. I think the Unwritten can see the whole present at once, and even turn time back a little."
"You think?"
"I'm guessing from the gaps. That's all anyone can do up there." He closed the book and held it up between them.
"And RANK 0 I'm calling the Fool, because what the hell else do you call it? It isn't anybody in this book. It's the paper. The blank before the 1st word and whatever's left after the last 1. The Fool can go back before time, to before anything started, and make blank pages that nobody's written on yet."
"That's a God."
"It's beyond a God. Gods are titles inside the story. The Fool is what the story's printed on." He turned the closed book over in his hands.
"Only 2 things I can think of could ever go back and watch the same story happen again. The Fool, and the blank voice that narrates it."
Holyyy Revenhart cooked something peak, let me explain it a bit before the revalation...
Pay attention here, readers, because Revenhart just dropped his brilliant theory on the Narrative Ladder. Instead of measuring raw magical power, this ladder ranks how much you understand that your world is a story—and the higher you climb, the more you can manipulate fate and control the people below you.
Since Revenhart breaks most of it down using his own life, here is the quick cheat sheet for the 9 tiers (from Rank 8 to Rank 0) so you can easily keep track:
Rank 8 — The Reader: Ordinary people who blindly follow the life written for them, completely unaware that a bigger purpose even exists.
Rank 7 — The Listener: Talented thinkers who realize they will lose a fair fight against the world's powers, so they build tools and improvise to survive.
Rank 6 — The Character: Self-aware players (like Kaiser right now) who realize the story actively wants to kill them, so they read ahead to anticipate traps before they happen.
Rank 5 — The Scriptor: People who bend fate by ditching long-term plans and making up their lives on the spot, moving too fast for the plot to lock them down.
Rank 4 — The Weaver: Masterminds like Celestara and Azrian who braid together the beliefs, myths, and cultures of millions of people until that collective belief shifts fate itself.
Rank 3 — The Author: Someone like Revenhart holding the quill, who stands above the characters and directly writes what happens next in fate's future.
Rank 2 — The Dreamer: The higher entity who imagines and creates the Author while the Author is busy writing the story.
Rank 1 — The Unwritten: A cosmic observer who merely pictures the Dreamer into existence, capable of seeing the entire present at once and rewinding time.
Rank 0 — The Fool: Not a character or a God at all, but the literal blank paper the story is printed on—existing before time and capable of wiping the slate clean to watch the whole story happen again.
What makes this scene so wild is Revenhart admitting a massive flaw in his own rank: because Icelynn rebuilt him and handed him the quill, he jumped straight from Rank 5 to Rank 3, skipping Rank 4 completely.
He is an Author who never learned how to weave a story together, which is a huge reason why a Rank 6 Character like Kaiser is already outplaying his quill!
...
Icelynn worked it out a second before he said it, and hated that she needed the second.
"The narrator."
Revenhart nodded, and he turned around, slowly, and looked straight out of the room, past Icelynn and the orbiting books, toward a sudden direction.
"So if this is a story," he said, "and somebody's narrating it, then I have a question. Readers? Are you listening to me right now? Is there anyone in another dimension, past this one, reading this?"
"Evren," Icelynn said. "You're going crazy. You're literally talking to the wall."
"There's no wall in here."
"You're talking to the NOTHING, then!"
He kept looking.
...
He's a pretty smart individual, isn't he? Though I'd be a fool to talk to him right now. :)
Let's let him imagine a bit more.
How about that, readers?
"Nothing," Revenhart said after a long moment, and laughed. "Of course nothing. If I was narrating me, I wouldn't answer either."
"You are so weird."
"Here's what I think, though." He turned back to her. "If something is narrating us, the neutral voice in Elfaria's book isn't an accident. It's the same thing, smaller. Every book has a voice left over when you take the writer out. So whatever is narrating our world isn't the Author."
"It's the voice that killed the Author."
"Nobody kills an author. Authors just stop writing, duh."
"Look at Elfaria's book. The neutral voice only started writing the Axel pages after Elfaria stopped. So if our whole world has a narrator, then whoever wrote our world stopped writing, or got stopped. Whoever did that to the author of our story was either strong enough to pull it off or foolish enough to try."
"Either way, I know what to call them."
"The Fool."
"You're getting good at this."
For the record, readers, I'd like to state that I haven't killed anybody. 💝🩷
Probably. Let's move on.
"And the 2nd theory," Revenhart said, "is worse."
"Mhm?"
"Maybe nobody's narrating all of us. Maybe something at the top of that ladder is helping one person in particular. Something above me, watching him, stepping in exactly when the quill reaches his line. It would explain all 7 books."
"Something's protecting Kaiser?"
"Or Kaiser figured out how to climb the narrative ladder faster than anyone in history, all by himself, with no magic. Through sheer metacognition and intelligence"
"Honestly, I don't know which one scares me more."
He looked down at the 7 books still circling the couch, and his voice dropped.
"Because think about what the 2nd ones means. On my ladder he's still a Character, RANK 6, and a Character doesn't skip RANKS. The only way to climb as fast as he's climbing is to already know the ladder exists. That means he found it before I did, while I was still drawing it." He let out a breath.
"And if he found it 1st, then maybe he isn't climbing my ladder at all. Maybe he's climbing with methods neither Azrian nor I ever tried on our way to Godhood, and I haven't even thought of them yet."
"Or you're wrong, and he's a lucky psycho."
"Maybe. I'd honestly prefer that."
Here's the uncomfortable part, readers.
Revenhart might be right about everything he just said, or wrong about all of it, and there's a 3rd option nobody in this room wants to say out loud: that a magicless boy in Sylvaris has already read past the edge of this ladder, and is quietly standing on RANKS that aren't drawn on it.
Azrian reached for Godhood by weaving. Revenhart reached for it with a borrowed quill.
Kaiser is reaching for it some other way, and the only person who knows what that way is happens to be Kaiser.
There's 1 more idea he didn't say out loud, so I'll say it for him, since it's about me.
If somebody is watching a story, the people in it have to suffer, because nobody keeps reading a chapter where nothing happens. Think back. How many times have you watched Kaiser get a quiet morning and keep it all the way to lunch?
Revenhart has started to suspect that Kaiser and Elfina suffered as much as they did because they were the 2 most important people in the story, and the 2 people being watched the hardest.
He might be right.
I'm still watching...
Part 6: The Bet
They sat quiet for a while, with his book closed on his knee and the 7 Specter volumes still circling.
"So what now?" Icelynn asked. "You figured out the universe. Do we go kill the Fool?"
"No." Revenhart rubbed his eyes and laughed tiredly. "Now I admit my theory is incomplete. I don't know who the narrator is, I don't know what's helping Kaiser, and I don't know if anything I just said is true or just delusional. So let's not make any rash decisions. Let's just watch the war."
"That's your big plan? Popcorn?"
"Popcorn's optional. We've been watching him for months. Since the Grotesque War, he's done nothing. He went to a labyrinth, he went to Sylvaris, he lives a calm little life, doing good deeds every now and then, and we have had our eyes on him every hour of it. He's had no chance to make a single move. If I picked up the quill right now and wrote that Kaiser Everhart dies before lunch, he should die."
"And he wouldn't."
"Yeah... And I still don't know why."
Icelynn pulled her knees up to her chest.
"So that's it?"
"No. That's only the part we don't know yet." He turned to face her.
"My goal isn't Kaiser, Icelynn. It never was. My goal is to identify the ladder and climb it. A higher rank, and then a higher one. If there's a top, I want to stand on it, because whoever stands at the top of that ladder is the one who decides what this world is."
"The One True God. That's what I'm trying to become, and that's why I chose you to stand next to me."
She didn't look at him.
A normal human... No magic, no gift, no blessing...
He beat me in science with the fight jet incident. He beats me in magic, because the quill can't touch him. He beats me in strategy, because he outplayed us in 2013... This trash, magicless loser is better than me at all 3 things I've ever been good at... Praised for and loved myself for...
Maybe I'm not as smart as I think I am.
Maybe I never was.
Revenhart watched her go quiet.
She's counting her losses for the first time in her life.
"Hey. Icyy..."
She didn't look up, so he made her.
He put 1 hand on her waist and the other under her chin, and turned her face toward his, gently, until she had no choice.
"In my eyes," Revenhart said, "you're still the smartest person I've ever met. In either life."
"You're just saying that."
"I mean every word of it. You had dreams of your own, goals of your own, things you wanted to build that had nothing to do with me, and you set every one of them down to come drag a dead man back and stand next to him. Everything I'm doing, I'm doing for you." He held her gaze.
"I want to understand Kaiser Everhart, and then I want to bring him to our side. If he won't come, then once I know exactly where he stands on that ladder, I'll write a line strong enough to rewrite his ending, just an ordinary enemy... Either way, it ends the same."
"You're my only ally, Icelynn."
Her eyes were wet, and she was furious about it.
"D-Don't say it that way..."
"How should I say it?"
"Less nicely. You're about to make me cry... Stop it."
And then, because she's Icelynn, and because life had taught her she can't stay down.
She sat up straight and wiped her face with the back of her wrist.
"The war's going to happen," she said.
"Is it?"
"It's going to happen. I've been working every side of it for 4 years. The dragons are planning as we speak. Pandemonium's council is about to march an army out to steal Mariabell's glory. The elves are scared enough to do something stupid. And Azrian wants this exact same war, so his people are pushing from the other end. There is no way that magicless clown stops all of that by himself."
"This isn't 2013." Her voice went low and precise, the voice she only uses when she means it.
"And if he tries this time, we kill him!"
Revenhart smiled, a slow and genuinely happy smile, and Icelynn suddenly felt very uneasy.
"Then let's bet on it."
"Bet on what?"
"If the war happens and nobody stops it, you win. But if it stops," he said, "miraculously, and Kaiser never gets involved, never goes near it, never moves a single muscle, then I win, and it means he planned the whole thing. It means the war starting was just a mistake on his end, and he'd already placed his precautions years in advance, the same way you place yours."
"It means you might have an equal in this world who isn't me."
"That's not going to happen!"
"Then you have nothing to lose. If I win, you have to take him seriously. Him, Azrian and everyone else. No more 'useless guy,' no more 'retarded monkey.' You treat them as people who are as smart as you, until we've won."
...
"Fine! And if I win, you have to marry me!"
Silence.
Elfaria, somewhere in the 5th direction, made a noise that was not technically a word.
"Huh!?" said Revenhart.
"That's... I... it came out!" Icelynn's whole face went red from the collar up.
"I was frustrated! It's a frustrated bet! It's a placeholder! Pick a different—"
Revenhart leaned in while she was still in the middle of her sentence, 1 hand still on her waist and the other under her chin, and kissed her on the lips, slowly enough that she had time to stop talking and nowhere near enough time to think of anything else to say.
When he pulled back, she was still holding her breath.
"Deal," he said.
"D-deal..?"
"Yes. But you should know something, since it's a bet." He didn't let go of her chin. "I'd marry you either way. Win or lose. My heart's always been yours, and there isn't room in it for anyone else."
"Th-that's cheating. That's n-not how bets work, you can't just— you can't kiss somebody in the middle of a negotiation!"
"You're the one who started betting on marriage."
"Because I was FRUSTRATED!"
"You're cute when you're frustrated."
"I'm n-not cute, I'm a genius."
"You can be both. My darling cute genius." He tilted his head.
"And.. if you ever refused me, I'd do absolutely everything in my power to make you love me. I'd chase you for the rest of eternity, Icelynn, because you're the one person I can trust with my heart."
"I'm NOT refusing!" Icelynn said, much too loudly, with her eyes very wide and her mouth in a small, outraged, extremely embarrassed little O.
"Who said refusing?! I d-didn't say refusing! I would never... and you don't have to ch-chase anybody, I'm right here, I've been right here the whole time, you absolute— stop smiling at me!"
"Cutie~"
"AUGH."
She collapsed forward into his chest and wrapped both arms around him so tightly that he wheezed, and she stayed there with her face hidden, because there are some expressions the smartest woman in 2 worlds does not let anybody see.
"Aww my cutie couple! 🚀💍" Elfaria whispered.
"Shut up, Elfaria," said Icelynn, into his shirt.
Revenhart laughed and held her, and the book of his life lay beside them on the couch, open to its last written page with every page after it still blank, and somewhere far below their feet, in a stone palace on the coast of Raphaelis, at exactly 11:40, a queen with ink on her fingers was unrolling a map.
I asked you 2 chapters ago who actually starts a war, and now you've met them, a woman who has never lost a war she planned and a man who forgave the people who burned his soul, holding each other in a room with more directions than you'll ever see, and the scary part isn't anything they've done yet, readers, it's that they've finally learned how to read.
This is the significant character of Icelynn and Revenhart.
