Doubting Penny would rescue the day was justified by both Hayley and Theo. Perhaps, even by Patricia.
Why?
Because if the situation were reversed, they didn't think they would want to get involved.
This situation wasn't just about buying a company or hiring assistants. This was a crime, no matter how one twisted the narrative.
Besides, they all knew that Penny wasn't the hero type. If anything, she might as well be an anti-hero.
Penny had already helped the Miller Company, regardless of how the Millers treated her in the beginning. She also hired Patricia, even when the latter was not qualified. As for Hayley, she had already earned an early mercy by being given a chance for the interview.
What else could they ask of her?
Thus, when Theo opened the door and saw the person standing outside, his knees buckled. His front bravado quickly melted as he sagged against the doorframe.